Home › Trends7

Who Is Better: Tyjae Spears Or Javonte Williams? Unveiling The NFL's Rising Stars

Trends January 12, 2025

As a fantasy football manager, you're always looking for that diamond in the rough, that player who can come out of nowhere and help you win your league. This year, that player could be Tyjae Spears or Javonte Williams.

Both Spears and Williams are talented running backs who are entering their second seasons in the NFL. Spears is a rookie who is expected to be the lead back for the Buffalo Bills, while Williams is a second-year player who is expected to share the backfield with Melvin Gordon in Denver. Both players have the potential to be fantasy football stars, but who is the better pick? Let's take a closer look at each player and see who has the edge.

Tyjae Spears is a 5'11", 215-pound running back who was drafted by the Buffalo Bills in the fifth round of the 2023 NFL Draft. He played college football at Tulane, where he rushed for over 1,000 yards in each of his last two seasons. Spears is a physical runner who is not afraid to lower his shoulder and get tough yards. He is also a good receiver out of the backfield, which gives him added value in PPR leagues.

Javonte Williams is a 5'9", 212-pound running back who was drafted by the Denver Broncos in the second round of the 2021 NFL Draft. He played college football at North Carolina, where he rushed for over 1,400 yards and 18 touchdowns in his final season. Williams is a versatile running back who can do it all. He is a good runner between the tackles, he can catch passes out of the backfield, and he is also a threat to score on special teams.

So, who is the better pick between Tyjae Spears and Javonte Williams? Both players have the potential to be fantasy football stars, but Williams has the edge in experience and versatility. He is also in a better situation in Denver, where he will be the lead back in a high-powered offense. Spears is a talented player, but he is still a rookie and he will have to prove himself in the NFL. If you're looking for a safe pick, then Williams is the better choice. But if you're looking for a player with upside, then Spears is the better pick.

Ultimately, the decision of who to pick between Tyjae Spears and Javonte Williams is up to you. Both players have the potential to be fantasy football stars, so you can't go wrong with either one. But if you're looking for a safe pick, then Williams is the better choice. And if you're looking for a player with upside, then Spears is the better pick.

Tyjae Spears or Javonte Williams

When evaluating Tyjae Spears or Javonte Williams for fantasy football, several key aspects should be considered:

Position: Both players are running backs.
Age: Spears is 23 years old, while Williams is 22 years old.
Experience: Williams has more NFL experience than Spears, having played in 17 games compared to Spears' 0.
Team: Spears plays for the Buffalo Bills, while Williams plays for the Denver Broncos.
Offensive Scheme: The Bills run a spread offense that utilizes multiple running backs, while the Broncos run a more traditional offense that features a lead running back.
Injury History: Spears has no significant injury history, while Williams missed four games in 2022 due to a knee injury.
ADP: Spears' ADP is currently in the 10th round, while Williams' ADP is currently in the 6th round.

These key aspects can help fantasy football managers make an informed decision about which player to draft. Williams has the edge in experience and ADP, but Spears has the potential to be a breakout star in 2023. Ultimately, the decision of who to draft depends on each manager's individual team needs and preferences.

1. Position

The position that Tyjae Spears and Javonte Williams play is a key factor to consider when evaluating them for fantasy football. Running backs are responsible for carrying the ball, blocking for other players, and catching passes out of the backfield. They are typically the most versatile players on the field, and they can have a major impact on the outcome of a game.

Facet 1: Ball Carrying
As running backs, Spears and Williams are responsible for carrying the ball and gaining yards. They must be able to run through tackles, break tackles, and find holes in the defense. Both players have shown good ball-carrying skills in their respective careers.
Facet 2: Blocking
In addition to carrying the ball, running backs are also responsible for blocking for other players, particularly the quarterback. They must be able to pick up blitzes, seal off holes, and create running lanes for their teammates. Both Spears and Williams are willing and able blockers.
Facet 3: Receiving
In today's NFL, running backs are also expected to be able to catch passes out of the backfield. They can be used as check-down options, screen pass targets, or even deep threats. Both Spears and Williams have shown good receiving skills in their respective careers.
Facet 4: Versatility
The versatility of running backs is a key factor to consider when evaluating them for fantasy football. Running backs who can do it all are more valuable than running backs who are one-dimensional. Both Spears and Williams are versatile running backs who can contribute in all three phases of the game.

Overall, the fact that Tyjae Spears and Javonte Williams are both running backs is a positive for their fantasy football value. Running backs are typically the most versatile players on the field, and they can have a major impact on the outcome of a game. When evaluating Spears and Williams for fantasy football, managers should consider their ball-carrying, blocking, receiving, and versatility skills.

2. Age

The age of Tyjae Spears and Javonte Williams is a factor to consider when evaluating them for fantasy football. Spears is 23 years old, while Williams is 22 years old. This means that Williams has one year of NFL experience over Spears. In general, older players have an advantage over younger players in the NFL because they have more experience and are more likely to be in their prime. However, there are many examples of young players who have had successful NFL careers, so age is not always a determining factor.

When evaluating Spears and Williams, it is important to consider their age in relation to their other attributes. For example, Spears is a rookie, but he has shown good ball-carrying, blocking, receiving, and versatility skills in his preseason appearances. Williams is a second-year player, but he has already shown that he can be a productive NFL running back. He rushed for over 900 yards and scored 7 touchdowns in his rookie season.

Ultimately, the age of Tyjae Spears and Javonte Williams is just one factor to consider when evaluating them for fantasy football. Other factors, such as their experience, team, offensive scheme, injury history, and ADP, should also be considered. However, age is still a relevant factor, and it is something that fantasy football managers should keep in mind when making their draft decisions.

3. Experience

The difference in experience between Tyjae Spears and Javonte Williams is a significant factor to consider when evaluating them for fantasy football. Williams has played in 17 NFL games, while Spears has played in 0. This means that Williams has a significant advantage over Spears in terms of experience. He has faced NFL defenses, played in different offensive schemes, and has had to adjust to the speed and physicality of the NFL game. Spears, on the other hand, has not yet played in an NFL game. He will have to adjust to the NFL game, and he may not be as productive as Williams in his rookie season.

The importance of experience in the NFL cannot be overstated. The NFL is a very competitive league, and players need time to develop and learn how to succeed. Williams has already shown that he can be a productive NFL running back. He rushed for over 900 yards and scored 7 touchdowns in his rookie season. Spears has not yet proven himself at the NFL level. He will need to have a strong rookie season in order to prove that he can be a fantasy football asset.

When evaluating Tyjae Spears and Javonte Williams for fantasy football, it is important to consider their experience. Williams has a significant advantage over Spears in this area. He has played in more NFL games, and he has proven that he can be a productive NFL running back. Spears, on the other hand, has not yet played in an NFL game. He will need to have a strong rookie season in order to prove that he can be a fantasy football asset.

4. Team

The teams that Tyjae Spears and Javonte Williams play for are important factors to consider when evaluating them for fantasy football. The Buffalo Bills and the Denver Broncos have very different offenses, which will impact the fantasy value of their running backs.

Facet 1: Offensive Scheme
The Buffalo Bills run a spread offense that utilizes multiple running backs. This means that Spears will likely share carries with other running backs, such as James Cook and Nyheim Hines. The Denver Broncos, on the other hand, run a more traditional offense that features a lead running back. This means that Williams is likely to be the lead running back for the Broncos, and he will get the majority of the carries.
Facet 2: Quarterback Play
The quarterback play of the Buffalo Bills and the Denver Broncos is also a factor to consider when evaluating Spears and Williams. The Bills have Josh Allen, who is one of the best quarterbacks in the NFL. This means that the Bills are likely to pass the ball more than the Broncos, which could limit the number of carries that Spears gets. The Broncos have Russell Wilson, who is a good quarterback, but he is not as good as Allen. This means that the Broncos are likely to run the ball more than the Bills, which could benefit Williams.
Facet 3: Offensive Line
The offensive line of the Buffalo Bills and the Denver Broncos is another factor to consider when evaluating Spears and Williams. The Bills have a good offensive line, which will help Spears get yards and score touchdowns. The Broncos have a weaker offensive line, which could limit Williams' production.

Overall, the teams that Tyjae Spears and Javonte Williams play for are important factors to consider when evaluating them for fantasy football. The Bills and the Broncos have very different offenses, which will impact the fantasy value of their running backs.

5. Offensive Scheme

The offensive scheme that a team runs has a major impact on the fantasy value of its running backs. The Buffalo Bills run a spread offense that utilizes multiple running backs, while the Denver Broncos run a more traditional offense that features a lead running back. This difference in offensive scheme will have a significant impact on the fantasy value of Tyjae Spears and Javonte Williams.

Facet 1: Number of Carries
In a spread offense, running backs are typically used more as pass-catchers than ball-carriers. This is because spread offenses rely on passing the ball to multiple receivers to move the ball down the field. As a result, running backs in spread offenses typically have fewer carries than running backs in traditional offenses.
Facet 2: Touchdown Opportunities
In a spread offense, running backs are less likely to score touchdowns than running backs in traditional offenses. This is because spread offenses typically pass the ball more than they run the ball. As a result, running backs in spread offenses have fewer opportunities to score touchdowns.
Facet 3: Pass-Catching Opportunities
In a spread offense, running backs are more likely to catch passes than running backs in traditional offenses. This is because spread offenses rely on passing the ball to multiple receivers to move the ball down the field. As a result, running backs in spread offenses have more opportunities to catch passes.
Facet 4: Blocking Responsibilities
In a spread offense, running backs are less likely to be used as blockers than running backs in traditional offenses. This is because spread offenses rely on passing the ball to multiple receivers to move the ball down the field. As a result, running backs in spread offenses have fewer blocking responsibilities.

Overall, the offensive scheme that a team runs has a major impact on the fantasy value of its running backs. Tyjae Spears plays for the Buffalo Bills, who run a spread offense. This means that Spears is likely to have fewer carries and touchdown opportunities than Javonte Williams, who plays for the Denver Broncos, who run a more traditional offense. However, Spears is likely to have more pass-catching opportunities and fewer blocking responsibilities than Williams.

6. Injury History

Injury history is an important factor to consider when evaluating NFL players, as injuries can significantly impact a player's performance and availability. Tyjae Spears has no significant injury history, while Javonte Williams missed four games in 2022 due to a knee injury. This difference in injury history could give Spears an edge over Williams in terms of fantasy value.

Injuries can have a major impact on a player's performance. A player who is injured may not be able to practice or play at their full potential, which can lead to decreased production on the field. In addition, injuries can sometimes linger and affect a player's performance even after they have returned from injury. For example, Williams' knee injury may have limited his explosiveness and agility, which could have impacted his production in 2022.

Availability is another important factor to consider when evaluating NFL players. A player who is injured may not be able to play, which can hurt fantasy owners who have drafted that player. Spears' clean injury history gives him an edge over Williams in terms of availability, as he is less likely to miss games due to injury.

Ultimately, the decision of whether to draft Tyjae Spears or Javonte Williams depends on a number of factors, including injury history. Spears' clean injury history gives him an edge over Williams in this area, but Williams' talent and potential upside could make him a more attractive option for some fantasy owners. Fantasy owners should weigh the pros and cons of each player and make the decision that is best for their team.

7. ADP

ADP, or average draft position, is a metric used in fantasy football to measure the average round in which a player is drafted. A lower ADP indicates that a player is being drafted earlier, while a higher ADP indicates that a player is being drafted later. In the case of Tyjae Spears and Javonte Williams, Spears' ADP is currently in the 10th round, while Williams' ADP is currently in the 6th round. This means that Williams is being drafted, on average, four rounds earlier than Spears.

There are a number of factors that can affect a player's ADP, including their performance in the previous season, their potential for the upcoming season, and their injury history. In the case of Spears and Williams, Williams' higher ADP is likely due to his strong performance in his rookie season, in which he rushed for over 900 yards and scored 7 touchdowns. Spears, on the other hand, is a rookie who has yet to play in an NFL game. As a result, his ADP is lower than Williams' ADP.

The difference in ADP between Spears and Williams is significant because it can affect their value in fantasy football. Players who are drafted earlier are typically more valuable than players who are drafted later. This is because players who are drafted earlier are more likely to be starters and to have a significant role in their team's offense. As a result, Williams is a more valuable fantasy football asset than Spears at this time.

However, it is important to note that ADP is just an average. There is a lot of variation in where players are actually drafted, and it is possible for a player with a high ADP to be drafted later than a player with a low ADP. Ultimately, the decision of where to draft a player is up to each individual fantasy football manager.

FAQs on Tyjae Spears or Javonte Williams

This section addresses common questions or misconceptions surrounding Tyjae Spears and Javonte Williams, providing informative answers to enhance understanding.

Question 1: Which player has a more favorable offensive scheme for fantasy football?

Javonte Williams has the advantage in this aspect. He plays for the Denver Broncos, who employ a traditional offense that typically features a lead running back. This means Williams is likely to receive a higher volume of carries and have more scoring opportunities.

Question 2: How does injury history impact the comparison between the two players?

Tyjae Spears has a clean injury history, while Javonte Williams missed four games in 2022 due to a knee injury. This gives Spears an edge in terms of reliability and availability, as he is less likely to miss games due to injury.

Question 3: Which player is a better value based on their ADP?

Javonte Williams has a higher ADP (Average Draft Position) than Tyjae Spears, indicating that he is being drafted earlier on average. This is likely due to his proven production in the NFL and his favorable offensive situation. However, Spears has the potential to be a value pick if he can earn a significant role in the Buffalo Bills' offense.

Question 4: How does each player's pass-catching ability affect their fantasy value?

Tyjae Spears may have an edge in PPR (Points Per Reception) leagues due to his potential to contribute as a pass-catcher. The Buffalo Bills' spread offense often utilizes running backs in the passing game, giving Spears opportunities to earn points through receptions.

Question 5: Who is the better long-term investment for fantasy football?

Both players have the potential to be valuable fantasy assets in the long run. Javonte Williams has already proven himself as a capable NFL running back, while Tyjae Spears has the talent and opportunity to develop into a star. The ultimate decision depends on individual team needs and strategies.

In summary, both Tyjae Spears and Javonte Williams have their own strengths and weaknesses. Fantasy football managers should carefully consider factors such as offensive scheme, injury history, ADP, pass-catching ability, and long-term potential when making their draft decisions.

Transitioning to the next article section...

Conclusion

In summary, Tyjae Spears and Javonte Williams are both talented running backs with the potential to be valuable fantasy football assets. Spears is a rookie with a clean injury history and a versatile skill set, while Williams is a second-year player who has already proven his ability to produce at the NFL level. Both players have their own strengths and weaknesses, and fantasy managers should carefully consider their individual team needs and strategies when making their draft decisions.

Ultimately, the best decision for your fantasy team will depend on a number of factors, including your league's scoring system, your team's other players, and your own personal preferences. However, regardless of which player you choose, both Spears and Williams have the potential to be key contributors to your fantasy success.