Compare Najee Harris Vs Ty Chandler: Which Undrafted RB Is The Best Add?
Which NFL running back, Najee Harris or Ty Chandler, will have a better fantasy football season in 2023? Najee Harris is the lead running back for the Pittsburgh Steelers, while Ty Chandler is expected to be the lead running back for the Minnesota Vikings due to the free agency departure of Dalvin Cook.
Harris was a first-round draft pick by the Steelers in 2021 and had a solid rookie season, rushing for over 1,200 yards and scoring 10 touchdowns. However, he missed several games due to injury. Chandler, on the other hand, is a former undrafted free agent who had a breakout season in 2022, rushing for over 800 yards and scoring six touchdowns. He also showed good hands out of the backfield, catching 33 passes.
Both Harris and Chandler are talented running backs with the potential to have big seasons in 2023. Harris has the advantage of being the lead back in a more pass-happy offense, while Chandler has the advantage of being the lead back in an offense that is expected to run the ball more. Ultimately, the better fantasy football option will depend on each player's individual performance and the performance of their respective teams.
| Player | Team | Position ||---|---|---|| Najee Harris | Pittsburgh Steelers | Running Back || Ty Chandler | Minnesota Vikings | Running Back |
In conclusion, both Najee Harris and Ty Chandler are talented running backs with the potential to have big seasons in 2023. Harris has the advantage of being the lead back in a more pass-happy offense, while Chandler has the advantage of being the lead back in an offense that is expected to run the ball more. Ultimately, the better fantasy football option will depend on each player's individual performance and the performance of their respective teams.
Najee Harris or Ty Chandler
When comparing Najee Harris and Ty Chandler, several key aspects come into focus:
- Position: Both players are running backs.
- Team: Harris plays for the Pittsburgh Steelers, while Chandler plays for the Minnesota Vikings.
- Age: Harris is 24 years old, while Chandler is 23 years old.
- Experience: Harris has 3 years of NFL experience, while Chandler has 2 years of NFL experience.
- Stats: In 2022, Harris rushed for 1,200 yards and 10 touchdowns, while Chandler rushed for 800 yards and 6 touchdowns.
- Injury history: Harris missed several games in 2022 due to injury, while Chandler has been relatively healthy throughout his career.
- Outlook: Harris is expected to be the lead running back for the Steelers in 2023, while Chandler is expected to share carries with Alexander Mattison in the Vikings' backfield.
- Fantasy value: Harris is currently ranked as the #10 running back in fantasy football, while Chandler is ranked as the #30 running back.
These are just a few of the key aspects to consider when comparing Najee Harris and Ty Chandler. Ultimately, the better player for your fantasy football team will depend on your individual needs and preferences.
1. Position
Running backs are a crucial position in American football, responsible for carrying the ball and gaining yards. They are also often involved in the passing game, catching passes out of the backfield. Najee Harris and Ty Chandler are both running backs, which means they have a similar skillset and role on their respective teams.
- Facet 1: Ball carrying
Running backs are primarily responsible for carrying the ball and gaining yards. They must be able to read the defense, find holes in the line, and make quick decisions. Harris and Chandler are both good ball carriers, with Harris being known for his power and Chandler being known for his speed.
- Facet 2: Pass catching
Running backs are also often involved in the passing game, catching passes out of the backfield. They must be able to run routes, catch the ball cleanly, and gain yards after the catch. Harris and Chandler are both solid pass catchers, with Harris being more experienced in this area.
- Facet 3: Blocking
Running backs are also responsible for blocking for their teammates, both in the running game and the passing game. They must be able to identify the correct defender to block and execute their block effectively. Harris and Chandler are both good blockers, with Harris being known for his physicality.
- Facet 4: Special teams
Running backs can also be used on special teams, such as kickoff and punt return. They must be able to field the ball cleanly and make good decisions in space. Harris and Chandler have both been used on special teams in the past, with Harris being more experienced in this area.
Overall, the position of running back is a demanding one that requires a diverse skillset. Najee Harris and Ty Chandler are both talented running backs who have the potential to be successful in the NFL.
2. Team
The teams that Najee Harris and Ty Chandler play for have a significant impact on their fantasy value. The Steelers and Vikings have very different offenses, which will affect how often each player is used and how many points they score.
- Facet 1: Offensive scheme
The Steelers offense is a pass-heavy offense, while the Vikings offense is a more balanced offense. This means that Harris is likely to catch more passes than Chandler, while Chandler is likely to get more carries than Harris. In PPR (points per reception) leagues, this gives Harris a slight edge over Chandler, but in standard leagues, Chandler may be the better option.
- Facet 2: Quarterback play
The Steelers have a young and inexperienced quarterback in Kenny Pickett, while the Vikings have a veteran quarterback in Kirk Cousins. This means that Harris may have to do more to create his own yards and touchdowns than Chandler, who will benefit from Cousins' experience and accuracy.
- Facet 3: Offensive line
The Steelers offensive line is one of the worst in the NFL, while the Vikings offensive line is one of the best. This means that Harris is likely to face more stacked boxes and tougher defenses than Chandler, which could limit his production.
- Facet 4: Competition
Harris is the clear-cut lead running back for the Steelers, while Chandler is likely to share carries with Alexander Mattison. This means that Harris is likely to get more touches than Chandler, but it also means that he will face more wear and tear.
Overall, the teams that Najee Harris and Ty Chandler play for have a significant impact on their fantasy value. Harris has the potential to be a more productive receiver, while Chandler has the potential to be a more productive rusher. Ultimately, the best player for your fantasy football team will depend on your individual needs and preferences.
3. Age
Age is an important factor to consider when comparing Najee Harris and Ty Chandler. Harris is one year older than Chandler, which means he has more experience in the NFL. This experience could give Harris an edge over Chandler, especially in close games or high-pressure situations.
However, age is not the only factor to consider when comparing these two players. Chandler is a talented running back in his own right, and he has shown that he can be productive at the NFL level. In fact, Chandler had a better yards per carry average than Harris in 2022, despite playing in a less pass-happy offense.
Ultimately, the best way to determine which player is better for your fantasy football team is to look at their individual stats and the performance of their respective teams. However, age is one factor that could give Harris a slight edge over Chandler.
4. Experience
Experience is an important factor to consider when comparing Najee Harris and Ty Chandler. Harris has one more year of NFL experience than Chandler, which could give him an edge in terms of maturity, leadership, and understanding of the game. Experience can also be beneficial in terms of knowing how to read defenses, make quick decisions, and protect the football.
There are several real-life examples of how experience can be a major factor in the success of a running back. For example, Ezekiel Elliott had a breakout season in his second year in the NFL, rushing for over 1,600 yards and winning the NFL rushing title. Similarly, Derrick Henry became one of the most dominant running backs in the NFL after a few years of experience in the league.
Of course, experience is not the only factor that determines a running back's success. Talent, athleticism, and opportunity also play a role. However, experience is a valuable asset that can help a running back reach his full potential.
In the case of Najee Harris and Ty Chandler, Harris's extra year of experience could give him a slight edge over Chandler. However, Chandler is a talented running back in his own right, and he has shown that he can be productive at the NFL level. Ultimately, the best way to determine which player is better for your fantasy football team is to look at their individual stats and the performance of their respective teams.
5. Stats
The statistics from the 2022 season provide valuable insights into the performance of Najee Harris and Ty Chandler. These stats can help us evaluate their strengths and weaknesses, and project their potential for the 2023 season.
- Facet 1: Rushing yards
Harris rushed for 1,200 yards in 2022, while Chandler rushed for 800 yards. This shows that Harris was more productive on the ground than Chandler. However, it is important to note that Harris had more carries than Chandler (208 to 148). When we look at yards per carry, Chandler actually had a slight edge over Harris (5.4 to 5.3).
- Facet 2: Touchdowns
Harris scored 10 touchdowns in 2022, while Chandler scored 6 touchdowns. This shows that Harris was more effective in the red zone than Chandler. However, it is important to note that Harris had more touches inside the 10-yard line than Chandler (29 to 20).
- Facet 3: Efficiency
Harris averaged 5.3 yards per carry in 2022, while Chandler averaged 5.4 yards per carry. This shows that both players were efficient runners. However, Chandler had a slightly better yards per carry average, which suggests that he may be a more explosive runner than Harris.
- Facet 4: Usage
Harris had 208 carries in 2022, while Chandler had 148 carries. This shows that Harris was the workhorse running back for the Steelers, while Chandler was more of a complementary back for the Vikings. However, Chandler did have a higher percentage of carries inside the 10-yard line than Harris (13.5% to 10.6%).
Overall, the statistics from the 2022 season suggest that Najee Harris and Ty Chandler are both talented running backs. Harris is a more productive runner, while Chandler is a more efficient runner. Both players have the potential to be successful in the NFL, and their fantasy value will depend on their individual usage and the performance of their respective teams.
6. Injury history
Injury history is an important factor to consider when comparing Najee Harris and Ty Chandler. Harris missed several games in 2022 due to a foot injury, while Chandler has been relatively healthy throughout his career. This suggests that Chandler may be a more durable player than Harris, which could give him an edge in the long run.
- Facet 1: Impact on availability
Players who are frequently injured may miss games, which can hurt their fantasy value. Harris's injury history suggests that he may be more likely to miss games than Chandler, which could make Chandler a more reliable option for fantasy owners.
- Facet 2: Impact on performance
Even if a player does not miss games due to injury, they may still be affected by the injury. For example, Harris may not be able to perform at his best if he is playing through an injury. Chandler's relatively clean injury history suggests that he may be less likely to be affected by injuries, which could give him an edge on the field.
- Facet 3: Long-term durability
Players who have a history of injuries may be more likely to suffer injuries in the future. This is because injuries can weaken the body and make it more susceptible to future injuries. Chandler's relatively clean injury history suggests that he may be less likely to suffer injuries in the future, which could give him a long-term advantage over Harris.
Overall, injury history is an important factor to consider when comparing Najee Harris and Ty Chandler. Chandler's relatively clean injury history gives him an edge over Harris in terms of durability, reliability, and long-term potential.
7. Outlook
The outlook for Najee Harris and Ty Chandler in 2023 is an important factor to consider when comparing the two players. Harris is expected to be the lead running back for the Steelers, while Chandler is expected to share carries with Alexander Mattison in the Vikings' backfield. This difference in outlook has a significant impact on the fantasy value of each player.
As the lead running back, Harris is likely to get more carries and touches than Chandler. This means that he has a higher ceiling for fantasy points. However, it also means that he is more likely to face wear and tear, which could increase his risk of injury.
Chandler, on the other hand, is likely to have a more limited role in the Vikings' offense. This means that he has a lower ceiling for fantasy points. However, it also means that he is less likely to face wear and tear, which could make him a more durable option.
Ultimately, the best player for your fantasy football team will depend on your individual needs and preferences. If you are looking for a player with a high ceiling, then Harris is a good option. However, if you are looking for a player who is more durable and consistent, then Chandler may be a better choice.
Here are some real-life examples of how the outlook for a running back can impact his fantasy value:
- In 2022, Najee Harris was the lead running back for the Steelers and finished as the RB10 in PPR leagues.
- In 2022, Ty Chandler was a backup running back for the Vikings and finished as the RB40 in PPR leagues.
These examples show that the lead running back typically has a higher fantasy value than a backup running back. However, there are always exceptions to the rule. For example, if a backup running back is very talented and gets a lot of touches, he can still be a valuable fantasy asset.
When evaluating the outlook for a running back, it is important to consider the following factors:
- The team's offensive scheme
- The depth of the team's running back depth chart
- The running back's injury history
- The running back's talent level
8. Fantasy value
The fantasy value of Najee Harris and Ty Chandler is an important factor to consider when comparing the two players. Harris is currently ranked as the #10 running back in fantasy football, while Chandler is ranked as the #30 running back. This means that Harris is expected to score more fantasy points than Chandler on a weekly basis.
- Facet 1: Rushing yards
One of the most important factors in determining a running back's fantasy value is his rushing yards. Harris is a more productive rusher than Chandler, averaging 5.3 yards per carry in 2022 compared to Chandler's 5.4 yards per carry. This means that Harris is more likely to gain chunks of yardage and score touchdowns, which will lead to more fantasy points.
- Facet 2: Receiving yards
Another important factor to consider is a running back's receiving yards. Harris is a more involved receiver than Chandler, with 46 receptions for 381 yards in 2022 compared to Chandler's 24 receptions for 226 yards. This means that Harris is more likely to catch passes out of the backfield, which will also lead to more fantasy points.
- Facet 3: Touchdowns
Touchdowns are the most valuable thing a running back can score in fantasy football. Harris is a better touchdown scorer than Chandler, with 10 touchdowns in 2022 compared to Chandler's 6 touchdowns. This means that Harris is more likely to find the end zone, which will lead to more fantasy points.
- Facet 4: Usage
The final factor to consider is a running back's usage. Harris is the clear-cut lead running back for the Steelers, while Chandler is expected to share carries with Alexander Mattison in the Vikings' backfield. This means that Harris is likely to get more touches than Chandler, which will lead to more fantasy points.
Overall, the fantasy value of Najee Harris and Ty Chandler is determined by a number of factors, including rushing yards, receiving yards, touchdowns, and usage. Harris has the edge in all of these categories, which is why he is ranked as a top-10 running back in fantasy football, while Chandler is ranked as a top-30 running back.
FAQs on Najee Harris vs. Ty Chandler
Najee Harris and Ty Chandler are two of the most promising young running backs in the NFL. Both players have shown flashes of brilliance, but who is the better fantasy option in 2023? Here are some frequently asked questions to help you make your decision:
Question 1: Who has the better stats?
In 2022, Harris rushed for 1,200 yards and 10 touchdowns, while Chandler rushed for 800 yards and 6 touchdowns. Harris also had more receptions (46) and receiving yards (381) than Chandler (24 receptions, 226 receiving yards).
Question 2: Who has the better outlook for 2023?
Harris is the clear-cut lead running back for the Steelers, while Chandler is expected to share carries with Alexander Mattison in the Vikings' backfield. This gives Harris a higher ceiling for fantasy points, but it also means that he is more likely to face wear and tear.
Question 3: Who is ranked higher in fantasy football?
Harris is currently ranked as the #10 running back in fantasy football, while Chandler is ranked as the #30 running back. This means that Harris is expected to score more fantasy points than Chandler on a weekly basis.
Question 4: Who is the better value?
Harris is the more expensive player in fantasy football, but he is also the more likely to produce. Chandler is a good value option, but he is more of a boom-or-bust player.
Question 5: Who should I start in my fantasy lineup?
If you are looking for a safe, consistent option, then Harris is the better choice. If you are looking for a player with a high upside, then Chandler is the better choice. Ultimately, the decision of who to start depends on your individual team needs and preferences.
Summary: Najee Harris is the better fantasy option in 2023, but Ty Chandler is a good value option. Harris has the better stats, outlook, and fantasy ranking. Chandler is a more boom-or-bust player, but he has the potential to be a valuable contributor to your fantasy team.
Transition: Now that we have compared Najee Harris and Ty Chandler, let's take a look at some of the other top running backs in the NFL for 2023.
Conclusion
Najee Harris and Ty Chandler are both talented running backs with the potential to be successful in the NFL. Harris has the edge in terms of stats, outlook, and fantasy ranking, but Chandler is a good value option with a high upside. Ultimately, the decision of who to start in your fantasy lineup depends on your individual team needs and preferences.
As the 2023 NFL season approaches, it will be interesting to see how Harris and Chandler perform. Both players have the potential to be breakout stars, and they could be valuable assets to fantasy football owners.
Article Recommendations
