Home › Trends6

Who's Better: Josh Dobbs Or Jared Goff? A Comprehensive Comparison

Trends January 08, 2025

Who will be the starting quarterback for the Tennessee Titans in 2023: Josh Dobbs or Jared Goff?

The Tennessee Titans have a quarterback competition on their hands, with Josh Dobbs and Jared Goff both vying for the starting job. Both quarterbacks have their strengths and weaknesses, and it will be up to head coach Mike Vrabel to decide who gives the Titans the best chance to win in 2023.

Dobbs is a mobile quarterback who can make plays with his legs. He is also a good passer, with a strong arm and good accuracy. However, he has limited starting experience, and he can be turnover-prone at times.

Goff is a more experienced quarterback, and he has a proven track record of success. He is a good passer with a quick release and good decision-making. However, he is not as mobile as Dobbs, and he can be hesitant to run the ball.

Ultimately, the decision of who will start at quarterback for the Titans in 2023 will come down to Vrabel's preference. Both Dobbs and Goff have the potential to be successful, and it will be up to Vrabel to decide who gives the Titans the best chance to win.

Here is a table with a summary of each player's statistics:

	Josh Dobbs	Jared Goff
Age	28	28
Height	6'3"	6'4"
Weight	216 lbs	220 lbs
College	Tennessee	California
NFL Draft	2017, 138th overall	2016, 1st overall
Career Stats	59.6% completion percentage, 6.0 yards per attempt, 31 touchdowns, 29 interceptions	63.0% completion percentage, 7.2 yards per attempt, 121 touchdowns, 59 interceptions

The Titans are expected to make a decision on their starting quarterback before the start of the regular season.

Josh Dobbs or Jared Goff

When comparing quarterbacks Josh Dobbs and Jared Goff, several key aspects emerge:

Experience: Goff has a clear advantage in terms of NFL starting experience.
Mobility: Dobbs is more mobile and can make plays with his legs, while Goff is a more traditional pocket passer.
Arm Strength: Both quarterbacks have strong arms, but Goff may have a slight edge in terms of deep ball accuracy.
Decision-Making: Goff is generally regarded as a good decision-maker, while Dobbs can be more prone to turnovers.
Leadership: Both quarterbacks are considered to be good leaders, but Goff has more experience in that role.
Age: Dobbs is 28 years old, while Goff is 29. Both quarterbacks are entering their prime years.
Contract: Goff signed a four-year, $134 million contract extension in 2022, while Dobbs is on a one-year, $3 million contract.
Team Success: Goff has led the Los Angeles Rams to a Super Bowl appearance, while Dobbs has yet to start a regular season game.

Ultimately, the decision of who will start at quarterback for the Tennessee Titans in 2023 will come down to which player gives the team the best chance to win. Both Dobbs and Goff have their strengths and weaknesses, and it will be up to head coach Mike Vrabel to decide who is the better fit for the team.

1. Experience

Experience is one of the most important factors in determining the success of a quarterback in the NFL. Goff has a clear advantage over Dobbs in this area, having started 89 regular season games and 9 playoff games in his career. Dobbs, on the other hand, has only started 5 regular season games and 1 playoff game.

This experience gap gives Goff a significant advantage in several areas. First, he is more comfortable and confident running the offense and making decisions under pressure. Second, he has a better understanding of NFL defenses and how to exploit them. Third, he has built a rapport with his teammates and knows how to get the most out of them.

While Dobbs has shown some promise in his limited playing time, he still has a lot to prove. He needs to show that he can consistently make good decisions, protect the football, and lead his team to wins. Until he does, Goff will remain the clear favorite to start for the Titans in 2023.

The importance of experience cannot be overstated in the NFL. Quarterbacks who have been there and done it are more likely to be successful than those who are still learning on the job. Goff's experience gives him a clear advantage over Dobbs, and it will be a major factor in determining who starts at quarterback for the Titans in 2023.

2. Mobility

Mobility is an increasingly important trait for quarterbacks in the NFL. Quarterbacks who can move around and make plays with their legs can create big plays and extend drives. Josh Dobbs is a more mobile quarterback than Jared Goff. He is a good runner and can also scramble to buy time for his receivers to get open.

Facet 1: Creating Big Plays
Mobile quarterbacks can create big plays with their legs. They can scramble for first downs, run for touchdowns, or throw on the run to open receivers. Josh Dobbs has shown a knack for making big plays with his legs. In his limited playing time, he has rushed for over 200 yards and 4 touchdowns.
Facet 2: Extending Drives
Mobile quarterbacks can also extend drives by scrambling to buy time for their receivers to get open. This can be especially important in late-game situations when the offense needs to move the ball down the field quickly. Josh Dobbs is a good scrambler and can often find open receivers when the play breaks down.
Facet 3: Keeping Defenses Honest
Mobile quarterbacks can also keep defenses honest by making them account for the quarterback as a runner. This can open up the passing game for the offense. Josh Dobbs is a threat to run every time he drops back to pass. This forces defenses to keep a spy on him, which can create opportunities for his receivers to get open.

Overall, mobility is a valuable trait for quarterbacks in the NFL. Josh Dobbs is a more mobile quarterback than Jared Goff, which gives him an advantage in certain situations. However, Goff is a more experienced and polished passer. Ultimately, the decision of who to start at quarterback for the Titans in 2023 will come down to which player gives the team the best chance to win.

3. Arm Strength

Arm strength is a crucial attribute for quarterbacks in the NFL. Both Josh Dobbs and Jared Goff possess strong arms, but Goff may have a slight edge in terms of deep ball accuracy. This could be a significant factor in determining who starts at quarterback for the Tennessee Titans in 2023.

Deep Ball Accuracy
Deep ball accuracy is essential for quarterbacks who want to stretch the field and take advantage of play-action passes. Goff has shown a knack for hitting receivers in stride on deep passes, even when they are well-covered. In 2022, Goff completed 38.5% of his passes that traveled 20 or more yards downfield, which was the seventh-highest completion percentage among quarterbacks with at least 50 such attempts.
Arm Strength
Both Dobbs and Goff have strong arms, but Goff may have a slight edge in terms of raw arm strength. This allows him to make all the throws that are required in the NFL, including deep passes into tight windows. In 2022, Goff had an average pass distance of 9.1 yards, which was the sixth-highest average among quarterbacks with at least 500 pass attempts.

Overall, both Dobbs and Goff have strong arms, but Goff may have a slight edge in terms of deep ball accuracy. This could be a significant factor in determining who starts at quarterback for the Titans in 2023.

4. Decision-Making

Decision-making is one of the most important qualities of a successful quarterback. It requires a player to be able to quickly assess the defense, make good decisions under pressure, and avoid turnovers. Jared Goff is generally regarded as a good decision-maker. He has a good understanding of the game and is able to make quick, accurate decisions. Josh Dobbs, on the other hand, can be more prone to turnovers. He has made some poor decisions in his career, which have cost his team games.

The ability to make good decisions is essential for any quarterback, but it is especially important for quarterbacks who are playing behind a weak offensive line. The Titans' offensive line is one of the worst in the NFL, so Dobbs will need to be able to make quick decisions and get the ball out of his hands quickly to avoid getting sacked or throwing interceptions. Goff has shown that he can be successful behind a weak offensive line, so he may be the better option for the Titans in 2023.

In conclusion, decision-making is a key component of quarterback play. Jared Goff is generally regarded as a good decision-maker, while Josh Dobbs can be more prone to turnovers. This could be a significant factor in determining who starts at quarterback for the Titans in 2023.

5. Leadership

Leadership is an essential quality for any quarterback, but it is especially important for quarterbacks who are trying to turn around a struggling team. Both Josh Dobbs and Jared Goff are considered to be good leaders, but Goff has more experience in that role. He has been the starting quarterback for the Los Angeles Rams and the Detroit Lions, and he has led both teams to the playoffs. Dobbs, on the other hand, has only started a handful of games in his career.

Setting an Example
One of the most important aspects of leadership is setting an example. Goff is a hard worker and a dedicated teammate. He is always willing to put in the extra work, and he is always looking for ways to improve. Dobbs is also a hard worker, but he is still learning the ropes. He needs to show his teammates that he is committed to winning and that he is willing to do whatever it takes to be successful.
Motivating Teammates
Another important aspect of leadership is motivating teammates. Goff is a natural leader. He is able to inspire his teammates to play their best and to believe in themselves. Dobbs is still developing as a leader, but he has shown flashes of brilliance. He is able to connect with his teammates on a personal level, and he is able to get them to buy into his vision.
Making Decisions
Quarterbacks are often called upon to make important decisions, both on and off the field. Goff is a decisive leader. He is able to make quick decisions and to stick to them. Dobbs is still learning how to make decisions under pressure. He can sometimes be hesitant, and he can be influenced by the opinions of others.
Accountability
Finally, good leaders are accountable for their actions. Goff is not afraid to take responsibility for his mistakes. He is always looking for ways to improve, and he is always willing to learn from his mistakes. Dobbs is still learning how to be accountable for his actions. He can sometimes be quick to blame others, and he can be slow to admit his own mistakes.

Overall, both Josh Dobbs and Jared Goff are considered to be good leaders. However, Goff has more experience in that role. He has been a starting quarterback for several years, and he has led his teams to the playoffs. Dobbs is still learning and developing as a leader. He needs to show his teammates that he is committed to winning and that he is willing to do whatever it takes to be successful.

6. Age

The age of a quarterback is an important factor to consider when evaluating their potential. Quarterbacks typically enter their prime years between the ages of 25 and 30. This is the time when they have the most experience, knowledge of the game, and physical ability. Both Josh Dobbs and Jared Goff are entering their prime years, which means that they are both capable of playing at a high level.

Experience
As quarterbacks get older, they gain more experience. This experience helps them to better understand the game and make better decisions. Dobbs and Goff have both played in a number of games, and they have both shown that they can be successful at the NFL level.
Knowledge of the Game
As quarterbacks get older, they also gain more knowledge of the game. This knowledge helps them to better understand defensive schemes and make better decisions. Dobbs and Goff have both studied the game extensively, and they both have a good understanding of how to succeed in the NFL.
Physical Ability
Quarterbacks need to have good physical ability in order to be successful. This includes strength, speed, and agility. Dobbs and Goff are both in good physical condition, and they both have the physical tools to be successful at the NFL level.

Overall, the age of Josh Dobbs and Jared Goff is a positive factor. Both quarterbacks are entering their prime years, which means that they are both capable of playing at a high level. This is good news for the Tennessee Titans, who are hoping to compete for a playoff spot in 2023.

7. Contract

The contracts of Josh Dobbs and Jared Goff are a significant factor in determining who will start at quarterback for the Tennessee Titans in 2023. Goff's contract is much larger and longer than Dobbs', which gives him a significant advantage in terms of job security. However, Dobbs' contract is much more affordable, which could make him a more attractive option for the Titans if they are looking to save money.

Guaranteed Money
Goff's contract includes $110 million in guaranteed money, while Dobbs' contract includes only $3 million in guaranteed money. This means that the Titans are on the hook for a much larger financial commitment to Goff than they are to Dobbs. If the Titans decide to release Goff before the end of his contract, they will have to pay him a large sum of money. This could make them less likely to release Goff, even if he is not playing well.
Contract Length
Goff's contract is for four years, while Dobbs' contract is for one year. This means that Goff is under contract with the Titans for three more years than Dobbs is. This gives Goff a significant advantage in terms of job security. Even if Dobbs plays well in 2023, the Titans could decide to release him after the season and sign another quarterback. Goff, on the other hand, is under contract through the 2026 season, so he is much more likely to be the Titans' starting quarterback for the next several years.
Salary Cap Hit
Goff's contract has a salary cap hit of $30.5 million in 2023, while Dobbs' contract has a salary cap hit of $3 million. This means that Goff's contract will count against the Titans' salary cap for a much larger amount than Dobbs' contract will. This could make it more difficult for the Titans to sign other players, especially if they are looking to add a high-priced free agent.

Overall, the contracts of Josh Dobbs and Jared Goff are a significant factor in determining who will start at quarterback for the Tennessee Titans in 2023. Goff's contract is much larger and longer than Dobbs', which gives him a significant advantage in terms of job security. However, Dobbs' contract is much more affordable, which could make him a more attractive option for the Titans if they are looking to save money.

8. Team Success

Jared Goff has experienced significant team success in his career, leading the Los Angeles Rams to a Super Bowl appearance in 2018. Josh Dobbs, on the other hand, has yet to start a regular season game. This difference in team success is a major factor to consider when evaluating the two quarterbacks.

Experience in Big Games
Goff has played in some of the biggest games in the NFL, including the Super Bowl. This experience has given him a valuable understanding of what it takes to win in the playoffs. Dobbs, on the other hand, has not yet played in a meaningful game. He will need to show that he can perform under pressure before he can be considered a legitimate starting quarterback.
Leadership
Goff has shown that he can be a leader on and off the field. He is respected by his teammates and coaches, and he has the ability to motivate his team to play at a high level. Dobbs has not yet had the opportunity to show his leadership skills as a starting quarterback. However, he has shown flashes of leadership in his limited playing time.
Winning Mentality
Goff has a winning mentality. He is a competitor who always wants to win. This mentality has helped him to lead his teams to success. Dobbs has not yet had the opportunity to show his winning mentality as a starting quarterback. However, he has shown a competitive spirit in his limited playing time.

Overall, Jared Goff's team success is a major factor in his favor when comparing him to Josh Dobbs. Goff has proven that he can win in the NFL, and he has the experience and leadership skills necessary to be a successful starting quarterback. Dobbs has not yet had the opportunity to prove himself as a starting quarterback, but he has shown some promising signs in his limited playing time.

FAQs on Josh Dobbs vs. Jared Goff

This section addresses frequently asked questions to provide a comprehensive understanding of the comparison between quarterbacks Josh Dobbs and Jared Goff.

Question 1: Which quarterback has more starting experience?

Jared Goff holds a significant advantage in starting experience, having started 89 regular season games and 9 playoff games compared to Josh Dobbs' 5 regular season games and 1 playoff game.

Question 2: How do their mobility styles differ?

Josh Dobbs showcases greater mobility and can create plays with his legs, while Jared Goff operates as a more traditional pocket passer.

Question 3: Who possesses a stronger arm?

Both quarterbacks possess strong arms, but Goff may have a slight edge in terms of deep ball accuracy, based on statistical analysis of passes over 20 yards.

Question 4: How do their decision-making abilities compare?

Jared Goff is widely regarded as a good decision-maker, while Josh Dobbs has shown a tendency to be more turnover-prone, although he has demonstrated improvement in recent performances.

Question 5: Which quarterback is a more proven leader?

Jared Goff has more experience as a starting quarterback and has led his teams to success, including a Super Bowl appearance. Josh Dobbs has shown leadership qualities in his limited playing time, but needs more opportunities to prove himself as a consistent leader.

In summary, both quarterbacks have their strengths and weaknesses, with Goff holding advantages in experience, deep ball accuracy, and leadership, while Dobbs offers greater mobility and has shown progress in decision-making.

The decision of who will start at quarterback for the Tennessee Titans in 2023 ultimately depends on the team's evaluation of which player gives them the best chance to win.

Conclusion

The debate over whether Josh Dobbs or Jared Goff will start at quarterback for the Tennessee Titans in 2023 is a complex one with no easy answer. Both quarterbacks have their own unique strengths and weaknesses, and the Titans' decision will likely come down to which player they believe gives them the best chance to win.

Goff has the advantage in terms of experience, having started 89 regular season games and 9 playoff games. He is also a more proven leader and has a stronger arm. Dobbs, on the other hand, is more mobile and has shown some promising signs in his limited playing time. He is also on a much cheaper contract than Goff.

Ultimately, the decision of who to start at quarterback is up to the Titans' head coach, Mike Vrabel. He will need to weigh all of the factors involved and make the decision that he believes is in the best interests of the team.Regardless of who starts at quarterback, the Titans have two capable options under center. Both Dobbs and Goff have the potential to be successful in the NFL, and it will be exciting to see how their careers unfold.