Home › Trends6

Who's Better: Devonta Smith Or Christian Kirk?

Trends January 13, 2025

Who is the better wide receiver: Devonta Smith or Christian Kirk?

In 2021, Smith had 91 receptions for 1,696 yards and 16 touchdowns. Kirk had 77 receptions for 1,239 yards and 10 touchdowns. Smith also had a higher yards per catch average (18.6) than Kirk (16.1). However, Kirk had a higher completion percentage (70.1%) than Smith (65.9%).

So, who is the better wide receiver? It's tough to say. Both Smith and Kirk are elite players, and they both have their own strengths and weaknesses. Ultimately, it depends on what you value in a wide receiver. If you want a player who can stretch the field and make big plays, then Smith is your guy. If you want a player who is more consistent and reliable, then Kirk is your guy.

Here is a table comparing the two players' stats:

| Player | Receptions | Yards | Touchdowns | Yards per catch | Completion percentage ||---|---|---|---|---|---|| Devonta Smith | 91 | 1,696 | 16 | 18.6 | 65.9% || Christian Kirk | 77 | 1,239 | 10 | 16.1 | 70.1% |

Ultimately, the decision of who is the better wide receiver is up to you. Both Smith and Kirk are great players, and they both have the potential to be even better in the future.

Devonta Smith or Christian Kirk

Age: Smith is 23 years old, while Kirk is 25.
Experience: Smith has three years of NFL experience, while Kirk has four.
Stats: In 2021, Smith had 91 receptions for 1,696 yards and 16 touchdowns. Kirk had 77 receptions for 1,239 yards and 10 touchdowns.
Team: Smith plays for the Philadelphia Eagles, while Kirk plays for the Jacksonville Jaguars.
Contract: Smith is signed through 2024, while Kirk is signed through 2025.
Salary: Smith is making $1.7 million in 2022, while Kirk is making $14 million.
Awards: Smith won the Heisman Trophy in 2020, while Kirk has not won any major awards.
Potential: Both Smith and Kirk have the potential to be elite wide receivers in the NFL.

When comparing Smith and Kirk, it is important to consider all of these factors. Smith has the edge in terms of age, experience, and stats. However, Kirk has the edge in terms of team, contract, salary, and awards. Ultimately, it is up to each individual to decide who they think is the better player.

1. Age

The age difference between Devonta Smith and Christian Kirk is a significant factor to consider when comparing the two players. Smith is 23 years old, while Kirk is 25. This means that Smith has two years less of NFL experience than Kirk. However, Smith has already proven himself to be one of the most talented wide receivers in the league, and he has the potential to be even better than Kirk in the future.

Experience: Kirk has more NFL experience than Smith, but Smith has already proven himself to be a top wide receiver in the league.
Potential: Smith has the potential to be even better than Kirk in the future.
Ceiling: Smith has a higher ceiling than Kirk.
Longevity: Smith is younger than Kirk, so he has the potential to have a longer career.

Overall, the age difference between Smith and Kirk is a significant factor to consider when comparing the two players. Smith is younger and has less experience, but he has the potential to be even better than Kirk in the future.

2. Experience

The experience gap between Devonta Smith and Christian Kirk is a significant factor to consider when comparing the two players. Smith has three years of NFL experience, while Kirk has four. This means that Kirk has one more year of experience playing in the NFL.

Playing time: Kirk has had more playing time than Smith, which means he has had more opportunities to develop his skills and learn the NFL game.
Game situations: Kirk has played in more different game situations than Smith, which means he has had more experience dealing with differentand making adjustments on the fly.
Quarterback play: Kirk has played with better quarterbacks than Smith, which means he has had more opportunities to catch passes from elite passers and learn from their experience.
Team success: Kirk has played on more successful teams than Smith, which means he has had more experience playing in big games and winning.

Overall, the experience gap between Smith and Kirk is a significant factor to consider when comparing the two players. Kirk has more experience playing in the NFL, and this experience has helped him to develop his skills and become a more complete player.

3. Stats

The stats from the 2021 season show that Devonta Smith had a more productive year than Christian Kirk. Smith had more receptions, more yards, and more touchdowns than Kirk. This is likely due to a number of factors, including Smith's better quarterback play and his more consistent role in the offense.

Smith's quarterback in 2021 was Jalen Hurts, who is a rising star in the NFL. Hurts is a mobile quarterback who can make plays with his arm and his legs. This gives Smith a big advantage over Kirk, who has played with less talented quarterbacks throughout his career.

In addition, Smith has a more consistent role in the offense than Kirk. Smith is the clear number one wide receiver for the Eagles, while Kirk is one of several talented wide receivers on the Jaguars. This means that Smith gets more targets and has more opportunities to make plays.

The stats from the 2021 season show that Devonta Smith is a more productive wide receiver than Christian Kirk. This is likely due to a number of factors, including Smith's better quarterback play and his more consistent role in the offense.

4. Team

The teams that Devonta Smith and Christian Kirk play for have a significant impact on their value as players. The Philadelphia Eagles are a more successful team than the Jacksonville Jaguars, and this gives Smith a number of advantages.

Quarterback play: The Eagles have a better quarterback than the Jaguars, which gives Smith a better chance to succeed. Jalen Hurts is a rising star in the NFL, while Trevor Lawrence is still developing.
Offensive line: The Eagles have a better offensive line than the Jaguars, which gives Smith more time to get open and make plays.
Offensive scheme: The Eagles have a more pass-happy offense than the Jaguars, which gives Smith more opportunities to catch passes.
Team success: The Eagles are a more successful team than the Jaguars, which means that Smith has more opportunities to play in big games and win.

Overall, the fact that Devonta Smith plays for the Philadelphia Eagles gives him a number of advantages over Christian Kirk, who plays for the Jacksonville Jaguars. These advantages include better quarterback play, a better offensive line, a more pass-happy offense, and more team success.

5. Contract

The contracts of Devonta Smith and Christian Kirk are significant factors to consider when comparing the two players. Smith is signed through 2024, while Kirk is signed through 2025. This means that Smith has one less year on his contract than Kirk.

Term: Smith's contract is one year shorter than Kirk's, which means that he will be a free agent sooner.
Value: Smith's contract is worth less than Kirk's, which means that he is making less money per year.
Guarantees: Smith's contract has less guaranteed money than Kirk's, which means that he is less likely to receive his full salary if he is injured or cut.
Incentives: Smith's contract has more incentives than Kirk's, which means that he can earn more money if he reaches certain performance goals.

Overall, the contracts of Devonta Smith and Christian Kirk are significant factors to consider when comparing the two players. Smith has a shorter contract, a lower salary, and less guaranteed money than Kirk. However, Smith's contract has more incentives, which means that he can earn more money if he reaches certain performance goals.

6. Salary

The salary difference between Devonta Smith and Christian Kirk is a significant factor to consider when comparing the two players. Smith is making $1.7 million in 2022, while Kirk is making $14 million. This means that Kirk is making more than eight times as much money as Smith.

There are a number of reasons for this salary difference. First, Kirk has more experience than Smith. Kirk has four years of NFL experience, while Smith has three. Second, Kirk has been more productive than Smith. In 2021, Kirk had 77 receptions for 1,239 yards and 10 touchdowns. Smith had 91 receptions for 1,696 yards and 16 touchdowns. Third, Kirk plays for a more successful team than Smith. The Jaguars are a perennial contender, while the Eagles are still rebuilding.

The salary difference between Smith and Kirk is a reflection of their different values to their respective teams. Kirk is a more experienced and productive player, and he plays for a more successful team. As a result, he is making more money than Smith.

The salary difference between Smith and Kirk is also a reflection of the NFL's salary cap system. The salary cap limits the amount of money that teams can spend on player salaries. This means that teams have to make tough decisions about which players to sign and how much to pay them.

In the case of Smith and Kirk, the Eagles decided to pay Kirk more money because they believe that he is a more valuable player. The Jaguars decided to pay Smith less money because they believe that he is still developing and has not yet reached his full potential.The salary difference between Smith and Kirk is a complex issue that is influenced by a number of factors. It is important to consider all of these factors when evaluating the two players.

7. Awards

The Heisman Trophy is the most prestigious award in college football, and it is given to the player who is considered to be the best in the country. Devonta Smith won the Heisman Trophy in 2020, which is a testament to his exceptional talent and skill.

Natural talent: Smith is a natural talent, and he has been playing football at a high level since he was a child. He has great speed, agility, and hands, and he is a very difficult player to cover.
Work ethic: Smith is also a very hard worker, and he is always striving to improve. He spends countless hours in the weight room and on the practice field, and he is always looking for ways to get better.
Leadership: Smith is a natural leader, and he is always willing to step up and take charge. He is a great role model for his teammates, and he always puts the team first.

Christian Kirk is also a very talented player, but he has not yet won any major awards. This is likely due to the fact that he has not yet had the same level of success as Smith. However, Kirk is still a young player, and he has the potential to be a great player in the NFL.

8. Potential

Evaluating the potential of NFL wide receivers is a multifaceted task that requires consideration of both physical and mental attributes. In the case of Devonta Smith and Christian Kirk, both players possess a unique combination of skills and traits that suggest they have the potential to become elite wide receivers in the league.

Physical Attributes
Both Smith and Kirk possess exceptional physical attributes that make them well-suited to the wide receiver position. Smith, in particular, is known for his blazing speed and quickness, which allows him to create separation from defenders and make big plays down the field. Kirk, on the other hand, has a more well-rounded skill set, with good size, strength, and agility that make him a threat in all areas of the field.
Technical Skills
In addition to their physical attributes, Smith and Kirk both have excellent technical skills as wide receivers. Smith is a master of the deep ball, with a knack for making acrobatic catches and coming down with contested passes. Kirk, on the other hand, is a more polished route runner, with a diverse route tree and the ability to create separation from defenders with his quickness and agility.
Mental Attributes
Beyond their physical and technical skills, Smith and Kirk both possess the mental attributes necessary to succeed at the highest level. Smith is a highly competitive player with a strong work ethic and a burning desire to succeed. Kirk, on the other hand, is a more cerebral player, with a deep understanding of the game and the ability to make quick decisions on the field.
Production
While both Smith and Kirk have shown flashes of brilliance in their young careers, they will need to continue to produce at a high level in order to reach their full potential. Smith, in particular, has shown signs of being a true game-changer, with his ability to make big plays and score touchdowns. Kirk, on the other hand, has been more consistent throughout his career, and he has the potential to be a reliable target for his quarterback.

Ultimately, whether Smith and Kirk reach their full potential will depend on a number of factors, including their ability to stay healthy, their development as players, and the success of their respective teams. However, based on their physical attributes, technical skills, and mental makeup, both players have the potential to be among the best wide receivers in the NFL.

FAQs about Devonta Smith and Christian Kirk

Question 1: Who is better, Devonta Smith or Christian Kirk?

There is no easy answer to this question. Both Smith and Kirk are elite wide receivers, and they both have their own unique strengths and weaknesses. Ultimately, it depends on what you value in a wide receiver. If you want a player who can stretch the field and make big plays, then Smith is your guy. If you want a player who is more consistent and reliable, then Kirk is your guy.

Question 2: Who has more potential, Devonta Smith or Christian Kirk?

Both Smith and Kirk have the potential to be elite wide receivers in the NFL. However, Smith is still a young player, and he has shown signs of being a true game-changer. If he can continue to develop and stay healthy, he has the potential to be one of the best wide receivers in the league.

Question 3: Who is more expensive, Devonta Smith or Christian Kirk?

Christian Kirk is more expensive than Devonta Smith. Kirk signed a four-year, $72 million contract with the Jacksonville Jaguars in 2022, while Smith is still on his rookie contract.

Question 4: Who has more endorsements, Devonta Smith or Christian Kirk?

Devonta Smith has more endorsements than Christian Kirk. Smith has endorsement deals with Nike, Under Armour, and Pepsi, while Kirk only has a few minor endorsement deals.

Question 5: Who is more likely to win a Super Bowl, Devonta Smith or Christian Kirk?

It is difficult to say who is more likely to win a Super Bowl, as it depends on a number of factors, including the strength of their team and the performance of their quarterback. However, both Smith and Kirk are on teams with a chance to win a Super Bowl, so it is certainly possible that either player could hoist the Lombardi Trophy in the future.

Summary: Devonta Smith and Christian Kirk are two of the most talented wide receivers in the NFL. Both players have the potential to be elite players, and they are both on teams with a chance to win a Super Bowl. Ultimately, it is up to each individual to decide who they think is the better player.

Next Article: A more in-depth comparison of Devonta Smith and Christian Kirk, including their stats, strengths, and weaknesses.

Conclusion

Devonta Smith and Christian Kirk are two of the most talented wide receivers in the NFL. Both players have had breakout seasons in recent years, and they are both poised for even bigger things in the future. While Smith is a more explosive playmaker, Kirk is a more consistent and reliable target. Ultimately, it is up to each individual to decide who they think is the better player. However, there is no doubt that both Smith and Kirk are among the best wide receivers in the league, and they are both capable of making a big impact on their teams.

As the NFL continues to evolve, it is likely that we will see more and more players like Smith and Kirk. These players are not only great athletes, but they are also smart and versatile. They can line up in a variety of positions and they can be used in a variety of ways. This makes them invaluable to their teams, and it is why they are so highly sought after by NFL coaches and general managers.Overall, the future is bright for Devonta Smith and Christian Kirk. Both players have the potential to be elite wide receivers in the NFL, and they are both on teams with a chance to win a Super Bowl. It will be exciting to see how their careers unfold in the years to come.