Home › Trends4

Najee Harris Or Benny Singletary: Who's The Better Pick?

Trends January 14, 2025

Which NFL player will have a better season in 2023: Najee Harris or James Singletary?

Najee Harris and James Singletary are two of the most promising young running backs in the NFL, but which one will have a better season in 2023? Both players have their strengths and weaknesses, but here's a look at what each player brings to the table:

Najee Harris is a powerful runner with a strong lower body and good balance. He's also a good receiver out of the backfield, and he has the potential to be a three-down back. However, Harris is still relatively inexperienced, and he has some concerns about his durability.

James Singletary is a shifty runner with good speed and agility. He's also a good blocker, and he has the potential to be a valuable contributor on special teams. However, Singletary is also relatively inexperienced, and he has some concerns about his size.

Ultimately, it's too close to call which player will have a better season in 2023. Both Harris and Singletary have the potential to be stars, but they both also have some weaknesses that could prevent them from reaching their full potential. It will be interesting to see how these two players develop over the course of the season, and it will be even more interesting to see who ends up having the better season.

Personal details and bio data of Najee Harris and James Singletary:

Name	Position	Team	College	NFL Draft
Najee Harris	Running back	Pittsburgh Steelers	Alabama	2021, 1st round, 24th overall
James Singletary	Running back	Jacksonville Jaguars	Georgia	2021, 5th round, 164th overall

Main article topics:

Comparison of Najee Harris and James Singletary's strengths and weaknesses
Projection of which player will have a better season in 2023
Najee Harris's and James Singletary's potential and challenges
Historical context of running backs in the NFL

Singletary or Najee Harris

Najee Harris and James Singletary are two of the most promising young running backs in the NFL. Both players have their strengths and weaknesses, but they both have the potential to be stars.

Power vs. Finesse: Harris is a powerful runner with a strong lower body, while Singletary is a shifty runner with good speed and agility.
Experience: Harris has more NFL experience than Singletary, but Singletary has more experience in the SEC, which is considered to be the toughest conference in college football.
Draft Position: Harris was drafted much higher than Singletary, but draft position is not always an indicator of future success.
Team Situation: Harris is the clear-cut lead running back for the Pittsburgh Steelers, while Singletary is in a timeshare with Travis Etienne in Jacksonville.
Offensive Line: The Steelers have a better offensive line than the Jaguars, which could give Harris an advantage in terms of production.
Health: Harris has had some injury concerns in the past, while Singletary has been relatively healthy.

It is difficult to say which player will have a better season in 2023, as both players have their own unique strengths and weaknesses. However, Harris has the potential to be a three-down back and a workhorse for the Steelers, while Singletary may be more of a situational player in Jacksonville. Ultimately, both players have the potential to be successful in the NFL, and it will be interesting to see how their careers unfold.

1. Power vs. Finesse

The contrast between power and finesse is a key factor in determining which running back will be more successful in the NFL. Power runners like Najee Harris are able to break tackles and gain yards after contact, while finesse runners like James Singletary are able to make defenders miss and create big plays. Both types of running backs can be successful in the NFL, but they have different strengths and weaknesses.

Power runners are typically more effective in short-yardage situations and goal-line situations. They are also more likely to be used as lead blockers in the passing game. Finesse runners are typically more effective in the open field and on long runs. They are also more likely to be used as receivers out of the backfield.

The best running backs in the NFL are able to combine power and finesse. They are able to break tackles and gain yards after contact, but they are also able to make defenders miss and create big plays. Najee Harris and James Singletary are both young running backs with the potential to develop into complete backs. Harris has shown more power and Singletary has shown more finesse, but both players have the potential to be successful in the NFL.

The success of a running back in the NFL depends on a number of factors, including the offensive line, the scheme of the offense, and the individual talent of the running back. However, power and finesse are two key factors that will determine which running backs are successful in the NFL.

2. Experience

Experience is an important factor to consider when evaluating running backs. Najee Harris has more NFL experience than James Singletary, but Singletary has more experience in the SEC, which is considered to be the toughest conference in college football. So, which type of experience is more valuable?

There is no easy answer to this question. NFL experience is valuable because it allows players to adjust to the speed and physicality of the game. SEC experience is valuable because it allows players to compete against the best competition in the country. Both types of experience can be beneficial for running backs.

Ultimately, the value of a running back's experience depends on the individual player. Some players may be able to transition from college to the NFL more easily than others. Some players may be better suited to playing in a certain type of offense. It is important to evaluate each player on a case-by-case basis.

However, there is one general trend that can be observed. Running backs who have experience in both the NFL and the SEC tend to be more successful than running backs who have experience in only one of those leagues. This suggests that both types of experience are valuable and that running backs who have both types of experience are more likely to be successful in the NFL.

Here are some examples of running backs who have had success in the NFL after playing in both the NFL and the SEC:

Derrick Henry
Ezekiel Elliott
Alvin Kamara
Leonard Fournette
Todd Gurley

These are just a few examples, but they all demonstrate that running backs who have experience in both the NFL and the SEC can be very successful in the NFL.

Of course, there are also running backs who have had success in the NFL without playing in the SEC. However, these players are typically the exception rather than the rule. For most running backs, experience in both the NFL and the SEC is the best way to prepare for a successful career in the NFL.

3. Draft Position

The NFL Draft is an inexact science. There are many factors that can contribute to a player's success or failure in the NFL, and draft position is just one of those factors. There are many examples of players who were drafted high and failed to live up to expectations, and there are also many examples of players who were drafted late and went on to have successful careers.

Najee Harris and James Singletary are two examples of players who were drafted in different rounds but have similar potential. Harris was drafted in the first round, while Singletary was drafted in the fifth round. However, both players have the potential to be successful running backs in the NFL. Harris has shown more power and Singletary has shown more finesse, but both players have the talent and the work ethic to be successful.

The fact that Harris was drafted higher than Singletary does not mean that he is guaranteed to be more successful. Singletary has the potential to be just as successful as Harris, if not more so. It is important to remember that draft position is just one of many factors that can contribute to a player's success or failure in the NFL.

Here are some examples of players who were drafted in the first round but failed to live up to expectations:

JaMarcus Russell
Ryan Leaf
Robert Griffin III
Johnny Manziel
Sam Bradford

Here are some examples of players who were drafted in the fifth round or later and went on to have successful careers:

Tom Brady
Antonio Brown
DeSean Jackson
Darren Sproles
Tyreek Hill

These examples show that draft position is not always an indicator of future success. There are many other factors that can contribute to a player's success or failure in the NFL, such as talent, work ethic, and coaching. It is important to remember that draft position is just one piece of the puzzle.

4. Team Situation

The team situation is an important factor to consider when evaluating running backs. Najee Harris is the clear-cut lead running back for the Pittsburgh Steelers, while James Singletary is in a timeshare with Travis Etienne in Jacksonville. This means that Harris is likely to get more carries and touches than Singletary, which could give him an advantage in terms of production.

There are several reasons why the team situation is so important for running backs. First, the number of carries a running back gets can have a significant impact on his production. Running backs who get more carries are more likely to gain more yards and score more touchdowns. Second, the role of a running back in the offense can vary depending on the team situation. Some running backs are used as lead runners, while others are used more as pass-catching backs or situational players. The role of a running back can also change depending on the game plan and the opposing defense.

In the case of Harris and Singletary, Harris is likely to have a more significant role in the Steelers' offense than Singletary will have in the Jaguars' offense. The Steelers have a more established running game than the Jaguars, and Harris is the clear-cut lead running back. Singletary, on the other hand, is in a timeshare with Etienne, which means that he may not get as many carries or touches as Harris. This could limit Singletary's production, even if he is more talented than Harris.

Of course, the team situation is just one of many factors that can affect a running back's production. Other factors include the offensive line, the scheme of the offense, and the individual talent of the running back. However, the team situation is an important factor to consider when evaluating running backs, and it can have a significant impact on their production.

Here are some examples of how the team situation can affect a running back's production:

In 2021, Derrick Henry led the NFL in rushing yards despite playing in a timeshare with Dontrell Hilliard. However, Henry is a unique talent, and most running backs would not be able to produce at such a high level in a timeshare.
In 2022, Najee Harris had a disappointing season in his second year with the Steelers. One of the reasons for Harris's struggles was the fact that the Steelers' offensive line was one of the worst in the NFL. This made it difficult for Harris to find running lanes and gain yards.
In 2023, James Singletary could have a breakout season if he is able to win the starting job in Jacksonville. The Jaguars have a talented young quarterback in Trevor Lawrence, and they also have a solid offensive line. If Singletary can get enough carries, he has the potential to be a productive running back in the NFL.

These examples show that the team situation can have a significant impact on a running back's production. When evaluating running backs, it is important to consider the team situation in addition to the individual talent of the player.

5. Offensive Line

The offensive line is an important factor in the success of any running back. A good offensive line can create running lanes for the running back and give him time to find holes in the defense. A bad offensive line, on the other hand, can make it difficult for the running back to gain yards and score touchdowns.

Blocking: The offensive line's primary job is to block for the running back. This means creating running lanes for the running back and giving him time to find holes in the defense. A good offensive line will be able to open up big holes for the running back, which will allow him to gain yards and score touchdowns.
Pass Protection: The offensive line is also responsible for protecting the quarterback from being sacked. This is important because it gives the quarterback time to throw the ball to his receivers. If the offensive line is not able to protect the quarterback, he will be more likely to be sacked, which can lead to turnovers and lost yardage.
Communication: The offensive line must be able to communicate effectively with each other in order to be successful. This is because they need to be able to adjust to the defense's movements and make sure that they are all on the same page. If the offensive line is not able to communicate effectively, it can lead to breakdowns in the running game and the passing game.

The Steelers have a better offensive line than the Jaguars, which could give Harris an advantage in terms of production. The Steelers' offensive line is ranked 10th in the NFL, while the Jaguars' offensive line is ranked 29th. This means that Harris is likely to have more success running the ball with the Steelers than he would with the Jaguars. Of course, the offensive line is just one of many factors that can affect a running back's production. Other factors include the running back's talent, the scheme of the offense, and the opposing defense. However, the offensive line is an important factor, and it can give a running back a significant advantage.

6. Health

Health is an important factor to consider when evaluating running backs. Najee Harris has had some injury concerns in the past, while James Singletary has been relatively healthy. This could give Singletary an advantage over Harris in terms of durability and availability.

Injury History: Harris has missed several games due to injury in his NFL career, while Singletary has not missed any games due to injury. This suggests that Singletary is more durable than Harris.
Playing Style: Harris is a physical runner who often takes big hits. Singletary is a more elusive runner who is able to avoid big hits. This difference in playing style could lead to Harris being more likely to get injured than Singletary.
Age: Harris is 24 years old, while Singletary is 23 years old. This difference in age is not significant, but it is worth noting that younger players are generally less likely to get injured than older players.

Overall, Singletary has a slight advantage over Harris in terms of health. Singletary has missed fewer games due to injury, he has a less physical playing style, and he is younger than Harris. However, it is important to note that injuries can be unpredictable, and it is possible that Harris could stay healthy for the rest of his career. Ultimately, the best way to determine which player is more valuable is to look at their production on the field.

FAQs about Najee Harris and James Singletary

Najee Harris and James Singletary are two of the most promising young running backs in the NFL. Both players have their strengths and weaknesses, but they both have the potential to be stars.

Question 1: Who is the better running back, Najee Harris or James Singletary?

It is difficult to say who is the better running back, as both players have their own unique strengths and weaknesses. Harris is a powerful runner with a strong lower body, while Singletary is a shifty runner with good speed and agility. Harris has more NFL experience than Singletary, but Singletary has more experience in the SEC, which is considered to be the toughest conference in college football. Ultimately, both players have the potential to be successful in the NFL, and it will be interesting to see how their careers unfold.

Question 2: Which player will have a better season in 2023, Harris or Singletary?

It is too close to call which player will have a better season in 2023. Both Harris and Singletary have the potential to be stars, but they both also have some weaknesses that could prevent them from reaching their full potential.

Question 3: What are Harris's strengths and weaknesses?

Harris is a powerful runner with a strong lower body and good balance. He's also a good receiver out of the backfield, and he has the potential to be a three-down back. However, Harris is still relatively inexperienced, and he has some concerns about his durability.

Question 4: What are Singletary's strengths and weaknesses?

Singletary is a shifty runner with good speed and agility. He's also a good blocker, and he has the potential to be a valuable contributor on special teams. However, Singletary is also relatively inexperienced, and he has some concerns about his size.

Question 5: Who is the better value in fantasy football, Harris or Singletary?

Harris is the better value in fantasy football, as he is the clear-cut lead running back for the Steelers. Singletary is in a timeshare with Travis Etienne in Jacksonville, which could limit his production.

Overall, Najee Harris and James Singletary are both talented running backs with the potential to be stars in the NFL. It will be interesting to see how their careers unfold, and who has the better season in 2023.

Transition to the next article section:

Najee Harris and James Singletary are just two of the many talented running backs in the NFL. In the next section, we will take a look at some of the other top running backs in the league.

Conclusion

Najee Harris and James Singletary are two of the most promising young running backs in the NFL. Both players have their strengths and weaknesses, but they both have the potential to be stars.

It is difficult to say who is the better running back, as both players have their own unique strengths and weaknesses. It will be interesting to see how their careers unfold, and who has the better season in 2023.

Overall, Najee Harris and James Singletary are both talented running backs with the potential to be stars in the NFL.