Home › Trends15

Which Bears Running Back Is Better: David Montgomery Or Jerome Ford?

Trends January 12, 2025

Who will be the starting running back for the Chicago Bears in 2023: David Montgomery or Khalil Herbert?

With the departure of Tarik Cohen in free agency, the Bears' backfield is wide open for the taking. Montgomery and Herbert are the two most likely candidates to fill the void, but both players have their own strengths and weaknesses.

Montgomery is a physical runner who is known for his ability to break tackles and gain tough yards. He is also a capable receiver out of the backfield. However, he has struggled with injuries in the past and is not the most explosive runner.

Herbert, on the other hand, is a more dynamic runner who has shown flashes of brilliance. He is faster and more agile than Montgomery, and he is also a better pass-catcher. However, he is less experienced and has not yet proven that he can be a consistent producer.

Ultimately, the decision of who will start at running back for the Bears in 2023 will come down to which player can best complement quarterback Justin Fields. If the Bears want a physical runner who can help them control the clock and keep the defense honest, then Montgomery is their guy. If they want a more dynamic runner who can create big plays, then Herbert is the better option.

	David Montgomery	Khalil Herbert
Age	25	23
Height	5'10"	5'9"
Weight	220 lbs	210 lbs
College	Iowa State	Virginia Tech
Draft	2019, 3rd round	2021, 6th round
Career stats	1,427 rushing yards, 9 TDs; 70 receptions, 524 receiving yards, 3 TDs	412 rushing yards, 3 TDs; 17 receptions, 116 receiving yards, 1 TD

So, who will it be? David Montgomery or Khalil Herbert? Only time will tell.

David Montgomery or Khalil Herbert

When it comes to the Chicago Bears' backfield, there are two names that stand out: David Montgomery and Khalil Herbert. Both players have their own unique strengths and weaknesses, and it remains to be seen who will emerge as the team's lead running back in 2023.

Physicality
Experience
Versatility
Durability
Pass-catching
Vision
Blocking
Leadership

These are just some of the key aspects that will determine who wins the starting running back job in Chicago. Montgomery has the experience and physicality, while Herbert has the versatility and pass-catching ability. Ultimately, it will be up to Bears head coach Matt Eberflus to decide who is the best fit for his offense.

1. Physicality

When it comes to running backs, physicality is a key attribute. It encompasses a player's size, strength, and power, and it allows them to break tackles, gain tough yards, and score touchdowns. David Montgomery and Khalil Herbert are two running backs who possess a high level of physicality.

Montgomery is a powerful runner who is not afraid to lower his shoulder and take on defenders. He is also a good blocker, which is an important asset in the NFL. Herbert is a smaller back, but he is just as physical as Montgomery. He has a strong lower body and is able to generate a lot of power from his legs. He is also a very good tackler, which makes him a valuable asset on special teams.

The physicality of Montgomery and Herbert is a major reason why they are both considered to be starting running backs in the NFL. They are both able to handle a heavy workload and they are both capable of making big plays. If the Bears want to be successful in 2023, they will need Montgomery and Herbert to continue to be physical and productive.

2. Experience

Experience is one of the most important factors in determining the success of a running back in the NFL. It takes time to learn the nuances of the position, and to develop the instincts and skills necessary to be successful. David Montgomery and Khalil Herbert are two running backs who have both benefited from experience.

Playing Time
Both Montgomery and Herbert have had the opportunity toPlaying time in the NFL. Montgomery has started 32 games in his career, while Herbert has started 10. This experience has allowed them to develop their skills and learn from their mistakes.
Different Offensive Schemes
Montgomery and Herbert have both played in different offensive schemes. Montgomery has played in a more traditional power running scheme, while Herbert has played in a more spread-out, pass-happy scheme. This experience has given them a well-rounded understanding of the game and has helped them to become more versatile players.
Overcoming Adversity
Both Montgomery and Herbert have overcome adversity in their careers. Montgomery has battled injuries, while Herbert has had to prove himself as an undrafted free agent. These experiences have made them both stronger and more resilient players.
Leadership
Both Montgomery and Herbert are natural leaders. They are both respected by their teammates and coaches, and they both lead by example. This experience will be invaluable to the Bears in 2023.

The experience that David Montgomery and Khalil Herbert have gained in their careers will be a major asset to the Bears in 2023. They are both talented running backs who are ready to take on a bigger role in the offense. With their experience and leadership, the Bears can be confident that they have a solid foundation in the backfield.

3. Versatility

In today's NFL, versatility is a key attribute for running backs. Teams are increasingly looking for players who can do more than just carry the ball. They want running backs who can catch passes out of the backfield, block for their quarterbacks, and even line up as wide receivers. David Montgomery and Khalil Herbert are two running backs who possess a high level of versatility.

Montgomery is a well-rounded back who can do it all. He is a physical runner who is not afraid to lower his shoulder and take on defenders. He is also a good receiver out of the backfield and a capable blocker. Herbert is a smaller back, but he is just as versatile as Montgomery. He is a quick and agile runner who can make defenders miss in the open field. He is also a good receiver and blocker.

The versatility of Montgomery and Herbert is a major reason why they are both considered to be starting running backs in the NFL. They are both able to handle a variety of roles in the offense, and they can both make big plays in a variety of ways. If the Bears want to be successful in 2023, they will need Montgomery and Herbert to continue to be versatile and productive.

4. Durability

Durability is a key attribute for running backs in the NFL. The position is physically demanding, and players are often subjected to a lot of punishment. Running backs who are able to stay healthy and on the field are invaluable to their teams.

Playing Time
Running backs who are durable are able to play in a lot of games and stay on the field for a majority of the snaps. This allows them to make a significant impact on their teams' success.
Injury Prevention
Durable running backs are able to avoid injuries, or they are able to recover quickly from injuries. This allows them to stay on the field and contribute to their teams.
Longevity
Durable running backs are able to play for a long time in the NFL. They are able to withstand the rigors of the game and continue to be productive.

David Montgomery and Khalil Herbert are two running backs who have shown a high level of durability in their careers. Montgomery has played in 32 games in his career, while Herbert has played in 10. Neither player has missed a game due to injury.

The durability of Montgomery and Herbert is a major asset to the Bears. It gives the team confidence that they will be able to count on them to be on the field and make a contribution.

5. Pass-catching

In today's NFL, running backs are expected to be more than just ball carriers. They need to be able to catch passes out of the backfield and contribute to the passing game. David Montgomery and Khalil Herbert are two running backs who are both capable pass-catchers.

Route Running
Both Montgomery and Herbert are good route runners. They are able to get open against linebackers and safeties, and they have the hands to make catches in traffic.
Hands
Montgomery and Herbert both have good hands. They are able to make catches in stride, and they are not afraid to go over the middle and make catches in traffic.
Yards After the Catch
Montgomery and Herbert are both good at gaining yards after the catch. They are able to break tackles and make defenders miss, and they have the speed to turn short catches into big gains.
Overall Impact
The pass-catching ability of Montgomery and Herbert makes them both more valuable to the Bears' offense. They are able to create mismatches against linebackers and safeties, and they can help the Bears move the chains and score points.

The pass-catching ability of David Montgomery and Khalil Herbert is a major asset to the Bears. It makes them both more versatile and dangerous players, and it helps the Bears to be more successful on offense.

6. Vision

Vision is a key attribute for running backs in the NFL. It allows them to see the field clearly and make quick decisions about where to run and how to avoid defenders. David Montgomery and Khalil Herbert are two running backs who possess a high level of vision.

Field Awareness
Montgomery and Herbert are both very aware of what is happening on the field. They are able to identify open holes and cutback lanes, and they are able to adjust their running style to the situation.
Patience
Montgomery and Herbert are both patient runners. They are not afraid to wait for holes to develop, and they are able to make quick decisions about when to cut and when to go.
Explosiveness
Montgomery and Herbert are both explosive runners. They are able to accelerate quickly through holes, and they are able to make defenders miss in the open field.
Overall Impact
The vision of Montgomery and Herbert makes them both more effective running backs. They are able to make big plays, and they are able to help the Bears move the chains and score points.

The vision of David Montgomery and Khalil Herbert is a major asset to the Bears. It makes them both more dangerous players, and it helps the Bears to be more successful on offense.

7. Blocking

In the game of football, blocking is an essential element of success. It is the act of using one's body to impede the progress of an opponent, and it can be used in a variety of ways to create advantages for one's team. For running backs like David Montgomery and Khalil Herbert, blocking is a key part of their job.

There are two main types of blocking for running backs: pass blocking and run blocking. Pass blocking involves protecting the quarterback from being sacked by opposing defenders, while run blocking involves creating holes for the running back to run through. Both types of blocking are important, and both require a high level of skill and athleticism.

David Montgomery and Khalil Herbert are both excellent blockers. They are both strong and physical, and they have the technique and instincts to be effective in both pass blocking and run blocking. This makes them both valuable assets to the Bears' offense.

Blocking is often an overlooked aspect of the game, but it is essential for success. Running backs like David Montgomery and Khalil Herbert are key members of the offensive line, and their blocking ability helps the Bears to move the ball and score points.

8. Leadership

Leadership is a key quality for any running back, and David Montgomery and Khalil Herbert are two players who embody this trait. Both players are vocal leaders on and off the field, and they set a positive example for their teammates with their work ethic and dedication.

As leaders, Montgomery and Herbert are always willing to help their teammates improve. They are always available to answer questions, provide advice, and offer encouragement. They also lead by example, always giving 100% effort in practice and in games.

The leadership of Montgomery and Herbert has been a major factor in the success of the Bears' offense. They have helped to create a positive and productive environment, and they have been instrumental in helping the team to achieve its goals.

Here are some specific examples of how Montgomery and Herbert have demonstrated leadership:

Montgomery has been a vocal leader for the Bears since he was drafted in 2019. He is always willing to speak up and share his thoughts and ideas with his teammates. He is also a great role model for the younger players on the team, showing them what it takes to be a successful NFL player.
Herbert has been a leader on the Bears' offense since he joined the team in 2021. He is a hard worker and is always willing to do whatever it takes to help the team win. He is also a great teammate and is always willing to help his fellow running backs.

The leadership of Montgomery and Herbert is a major asset to the Bears. They are both players who lead by example and who are always willing to help their teammates. They are key members of the Bears' offense and are a big reason for the team's success.

FAQs about David Montgomery and Khalil Herbert

Here are some of the most frequently asked questions about David Montgomery and Khalil Herbert, two running backs for the Chicago Bears:

Question 1: Who will be the starting running back for the Bears in 2023?

Both Montgomery and Herbert are expected to compete for the starting running back job in 2023. Montgomery has the experience and physicality, while Herbert has the versatility and pass-catching ability. Ultimately, the decision of who will start will come down to which player can best complement quarterback Justin Fields.

Question 2: What are Montgomery's strengths and weaknesses?

Question 3: What are Herbert's strengths and weaknesses?

Herbert is a more dynamic runner who has shown flashes of brilliance. He is faster and more agile than Montgomery, and he is also a better pass-catcher. However, he is less experienced and has not yet proven that he can be a consistent producer.

Question 4: Who is the better running back?

Both Montgomery and Herbert are talented running backs with different strengths and weaknesses. It is difficult to say who is the better player, as it depends on what the Bears are looking for in a running back. If they want a physical runner who can help them control the clock and keep the defense honest, then Montgomery is their guy. If they want a more dynamic runner who can create big plays, then Herbert is the better option.

Question 5: What is the future of the running back position for the Bears?

The Bears have a solid foundation at the running back position with Montgomery and Herbert. Both players are young and have shown that they can be productive in the NFL. The Bears will likely continue to use a running back by committee approach in 2023, with Montgomery and Herbert sharing the workload.

Summary:

David Montgomery is a physical runner who is known for his ability to break tackles and gain tough yards.
Khalil Herbert is a more dynamic runner who has shown flashes of brilliance.
Both players have their own strengths and weaknesses, and it is difficult to say who is the better player.

The Bears have a solid foundation at the running back position with Montgomery and Herbert. Both players are young and have shown that they can be productive in the NFL.

Conclusion

David Montgomery and Khalil Herbert are two talented running backs who are expected to compete for the starting job in Chicago in 2023. Montgomery is a physical runner who is known for his ability to break tackles and gain tough yards. Herbert is a more dynamic runner who has shown flashes of brilliance. Both players have their own strengths and weaknesses, and it is difficult to say who is the better player.

The future of the running back position for the Bears is bright. Montgomery and Herbert are both talented players who have the potential to be stars in the NFL. The Bears are fortunate to have two such talented running backs on their roster.