Home › Trends11

Top Running Backs: Antonio Gibson Vs. Ty Chandler

Trends January 08, 2025

Who is the better NFL running back, Antonio Gibson or Ty Chandler?

Antonio Gibson and Ty Chandler are two of the most promising young running backs in the NFL. Both players have shown flashes of brilliance, but who is the better player? Let's take a closer look at each player's strengths and weaknesses to see who comes out on top.

Antonio Gibson is a 6'2", 228-pound running back who was drafted by the Washington Commanders in the third round of the 2020 NFL Draft. He is a powerful runner with good speed and agility. He is also a capable receiver out of the backfield. In his rookie season, Gibson rushed for 795 yards and 11 touchdowns. He also caught 36 passes for 247 yards.

Ty Chandler is a 5'11", 210-pound running back who was drafted by the Minnesota Vikings in the fifth round of the 2022 NFL Draft. He is a quick and elusive runner with good vision. He is also a willing blocker. In his rookie season, Chandler rushed for 231 yards and two touchdowns. He also caught 12 passes for 89 yards.

So, who is the better player? It's tough to say definitively, as both Gibson and Chandler have shown a lot of potential. However, Gibson has the edge in terms of experience and production. He is also the more versatile player, as he can be used as a runner, receiver, and blocker. Chandler is a very good player, but he needs to show more consistency before he can be considered one of the best running backs in the NFL.

| Player | Team | DOB | College ||---|---|---|---|| Antonio Gibson | Washington Commanders | 1996-06-28 | Memphis || Ty Chandler | Minnesota Vikings | 2000-04-05 | North Carolina |

Ultimately, the better player for your fantasy football team will depend on your individual needs. If you need a workhorse running back who can get you consistent yardage and touchdowns, then Gibson is your guy. If you need a more versatile player who can make plays in the passing game, then Chandler is a good option.

Antonio Gibson or Ty Chandler

When comparing Antonio Gibson and Ty Chandler, several key aspects emerge as crucial in assessing their abilities as NFL running backs:

Age: Gibson (26) is older than Chandler (22).
Experience: Gibson has more NFL experience than Chandler.
Size: Gibson is bigger than Chandler (6'2", 228 lbs. vs. 5'11", 210 lbs.).
Speed: Chandler is faster than Gibson.
Agility: Both players possess good agility.
Versatility: Gibson is more versatile than Chandler, as he can be used as a runner, receiver, and blocker.
Production: Gibson has produced more in the NFL than Chandler, with more rushing yards, touchdowns, and receptions.

These key aspects highlight the strengths and weaknesses of each player. Gibson has the edge in terms of experience, size, and versatility, while Chandler is faster and has more potential for growth. Ultimately, the better player for a particular team will depend on their individual needs and preferences.

1. Age

The difference in age between Antonio Gibson and Ty Chandler is a relevant factor when comparing their abilities as NFL running backs. Gibson, at 26 years old, is four years older than Chandler, who is 22. This age difference can have several implications:

Experience: Gibson has more NFL experience than Chandler. He has played in more games and has had more time to develop his skills. This experience can give him an edge in terms of understanding the game and making quick decisions.
Physicality: Gibson is bigger and stronger than Chandler. He may be better able to handle the physical demands of the NFL, including the wear and tear of a long season.
Maturity: Gibson is more mature than Chandler. He may be better able to handle the mental challenges of the NFL, including the pressure of playing in big games and dealing with the media.

However, it is important to note that age is not always an advantage. Younger players can often be more athletic and have more potential for growth. Chandler is a very talented player, and he could eventually surpass Gibson in terms of production. Ultimately, the better player for a particular team will depend on their individual needs and preferences.

2. Experience

The difference in experience between Antonio Gibson and Ty Chandler is a significant factor in their respective abilities as NFL running backs. Gibson has played in the NFL for three seasons, while Chandler is entering his second season. This experience gap gives Gibson a clear advantage in terms of understanding the game and making quick decisions.

For example, Gibson has a better understanding of how to read defenses and find holes in the line. He is also more comfortable making cuts and changing direction at full speed. This experience allows him to be more efficient and productive on the field.

In addition, Gibson's experience has helped him develop a stronger understanding of pass protection. This is an important skill for running backs, as they are often called upon to protect the quarterback from oncoming defenders. Gibson's experience in pass protection makes him a more valuable asset to his team.

While Chandler is a talented player with a lot of potential, he still needs to gain more experience in the NFL. As he continues to play and learn, he will likely become a more well-rounded player. However, for the time being, Gibson's experience gives him a clear edge over Chandler.

Key Insights:

Experience is a valuable asset for running backs in the NFL.
Gibson's experience gives him an advantage over Chandler in terms of understanding the game, making quick decisions, and pass protection.
Chandler is a talented player with a lot of potential, but he still needs to gain more experience in the NFL.

3. Size

The difference in size between Antonio Gibson and Ty Chandler is a significant factor in their respective abilities as NFL running backs. Gibson's larger frame gives him several advantages over Chandler, including:

Power: Gibson is a more powerful runner than Chandler. He is able to generate more force with his legs, which allows him to break tackles and gain yards after contact.
Durability: Gibson's larger size makes him more durable than Chandler. He is better able to withstand the physical punishment that comes with playing running back in the NFL.
Blocking: Gibson is a better blocker than Chandler. His larger size and strength make him more effective at blocking for his teammates.

While Chandler is a quick and elusive runner, his smaller size limits his effectiveness in certain areas. He is not as good at breaking tackles or gaining yards after contact as Gibson. He is also not as good of a blocker.

Overall, Gibson's larger size gives him a clear advantage over Chandler in terms of power, durability, and blocking. These advantages make him a more well-rounded running back and a more valuable asset to his team.

4. Speed

While Antonio Gibson has the advantage in terms of size and experience, Ty Chandler is the faster player. Chandler's speed gives him several advantages on the football field, including:

Elusiveness: Chandler's speed makes him difficult to tackle. He can change direction quickly and burst through holes in the line of scrimmage.
Big plays: Chandler's speed allows him to break away from defenders and score long touchdowns.
Versatility: Chandler's speed makes him a versatile player. He can be used as a running back, wide receiver, or return specialist.

Gibson's lack of speed can be a disadvantage at times. He is not as good at breaking away from defenders or making big plays. However, Gibson's power and durability make him a valuable asset in other areas of the game.

Overall, Chandler's speed gives him a clear advantage in certain areas of the game. However, Gibson's power and durability make him a more well-rounded player. Ultimately, the better player for a particular team will depend on their individual needs and preferences.

5. Agility

Agility is an important physical attribute for running backs in the NFL. It allows them to change direction quickly, accelerate and decelerate rapidly, and maintain balance while moving at high speeds. Both Antonio Gibson and Ty Chandler possess good agility, which gives them an advantage on the football field.

Gibson's agility allows him to make quick cuts and bursts through the line of scrimmage. He is also able to change direction quickly to avoid tackles and find open running lanes. Chandler's agility allows him to juke defenders and make sudden movements to gain yards after contact. He is also a good receiver out of the backfield, and his agility helps him to get open and make catches in space.

The agility of both Gibson and Chandler makes them valuable assets to their respective teams. They are able to create plays and gain yards in a variety of ways, which makes them difficult to defend. Agility is a key component of success for running backs in the NFL, and both Gibson and Chandler have it in spades.

6. Versatility

Versatility is a valuable trait for running backs in the NFL, as it allows them to contribute to their team in a variety of ways. Antonio Gibson is a more versatile player than Ty Chandler, as he can be used effectively as a runner, receiver, and blocker.

Rushing: Gibson is a powerful and elusive runner who can gain yards in a variety of ways. He is also a good pass protector, which makes him a valuable asset on third downs and in short-yardage situations.
Receiving: Gibson is a capable receiver out of the backfield. He has good hands and runs crisp routes, making him a reliable target for his quarterback.
Blocking: Gibson is a willing and effective blocker. He can seal off defenders in the running game and protect his quarterback on passing plays.

Chandler is a talented running back, but he is not as versatile as Gibson. Chandler is primarily a runner, and he is not as effective as a receiver or blocker. This limits his ability to contribute to his team in a variety of ways.

Overall, Gibson's versatility gives him a clear advantage over Chandler. Gibson is a more complete player who can be used in a variety of roles. This makes him a more valuable asset to his team.

7. Production

The production of a running back is a key indicator of their success in the NFL. Antonio Gibson has produced more in the NFL than Ty Chandler, with more rushing yards, touchdowns, and receptions. This is due to several factors, including Gibson's experience, size, and versatility.

Experience: Gibson has more NFL experience than Chandler. He has played in more games and has had more time to develop his skills.
Size: Gibson is bigger than Chandler. He is able to generate more power and break tackles more easily.
Versatility: Gibson is a more versatile player than Chandler. He can be used as a runner, receiver, and blocker. This makes him a more valuable asset to his team.

Gibson's production has been impressive in his first three seasons in the NFL. He has rushed for over 1,000 yards in each of the past two seasons and has scored a total of 18 touchdowns. He has also caught over 50 passes out of the backfield.

Chandler has shown flashes of potential in his first season in the NFL, but he has not yet produced at the same level as Gibson. He rushed for over 200 yards and scored two touchdowns in his rookie season, but he also had some fumbling issues. Chandler will need to improve his ball security and become more consistent in order to reach his full potential.

Overall, Gibson's production has been a major factor in his success in the NFL. He is a talented running back who has produced at a high level in his first three seasons. Chandler is a talented player with a lot of potential, but he has not yet reached the same level of production as Gibson.

FAQs about Antonio Gibson and Ty Chandler

This section addresses frequently asked questions about Antonio Gibson and Ty Chandler, providing concise and informative answers to clarify any misconceptions or concerns.

Question 1: Who is considered the better running back between Antonio Gibson and Ty Chandler?

Answer: While both players possess unique strengths, Antonio Gibson has a slight edge over Ty Chandler due to his experience, versatility, and consistent production in the NFL.

Question 2: How does Antonio Gibson's size impact his playing style?

Answer: Gibson's larger frame provides him with advantages in power, durability, and blocking ability, making him a well-rounded running back.

Question 3: What sets Ty Chandler apart from other running backs?

Answer: Chandler's exceptional speed and elusiveness allow him to change direction quickly, break tackles, and gain yards after contact.

Question 4: How has Antonio Gibson's experience in the NFL benefited his performance?

Answer: Gibson's experience has enhanced his understanding of the game, improved his decision-making, and made him more comfortable in pass protection.

Question 5: What areas does Ty Chandler need to improve upon?

Answer: To reach his full potential, Chandler needs to improve his ball security, become more consistent, and develop his skills as a receiver.

Summary: Antonio Gibson and Ty Chandler are both talented running backs with distinct strengths and areas for improvement. Gibson's experience, versatility, and production give him an edge over Chandler, but Chandler's speed and elusiveness make him a valuable asset as well.

Transition: Now that we have explored these common questions, let's delve deeper into the specific attributes that differentiate Gibson and Chandler as running backs.

Conclusion

The comparison between Antonio Gibson and Ty Chandler showcases two talented running backs with distinct strengths and areas for improvement. Gibson's experience, versatility, and consistent production give him a slight edge over Chandler. However, Chandler's exceptional speed and elusiveness make him a valuable asset as well.

Ultimately, the better player for a particular team will depend on their specific needs and preferences. Gibson is a more well-rounded back who can contribute in multiple facets of the game, while Chandler is a dynamic playmaker who can create explosive plays with his speed. Both players have the potential to be impact players in the NFL, and it will be exciting to see how their careers unfold.