Home › Trends11

Keenan Allen Or Diontae Johnson: Which WR Is Right For Your Fantasy Team?

Trends January 15, 2025

In the world of fantasy football, Keenan Allen and Diontae Johnson are two wide receivers who are often compared to each other. Both players have had success in the NFL, but who is the better choice for your fantasy team?

Keenan Allen is a 6'3", 211-pound wide receiver who has played for the Los Angeles Chargers since 2013. He is a three-time Pro Bowler and has led the NFL in receptions twice. Allen is known for his route running and his ability to make difficult catches.

Diontae Johnson is a 5'10", 183-pound wide receiver who has played for the Pittsburgh Steelers since 2019. He is a one-time Pro Bowler and has led the NFL in receiving yards per game. Johnson is known for his speed and his ability to create separation from defenders.

So, who is the better choice for your fantasy team? It depends on what you are looking for. If you want a wide receiver who is a consistent target and can be relied upon to make big plays, then Keenan Allen is your guy. If you want a wide receiver who can stretch the field and make big plays down the field, then Diontae Johnson is your guy.

Ultimately, the decision of who to start in your fantasy lineup is up to you. But if you are looking for a wide receiver who can help you win your league, then either Keenan Allen or Diontae Johnson is a great option.

Here is a table comparing the career stats of Keenan Allen and Diontae Johnson:

Player	Rec	Yds	TD
Keenan Allen	659	8,287	53
Diontae Johnson	201	2,531	17

Keenan Allen or Diontae Johnson

Keenan Allen and Diontae Johnson are two of the most talented wide receivers in the NFL. Both players have had success at the highest level, but who is the better choice for your fantasy team? Here are six key aspects to consider when making your decision:

Age: Allen is 30 years old, while Johnson is 26.
Experience: Allen has been in the NFL since 2013, while Johnson has been in the NFL since 2019.
Stats: Allen has more career receptions and receiving yards than Johnson, but Johnson has a higher career yards per reception average.
Team: Allen plays for the Los Angeles Chargers, while Johnson plays for the Pittsburgh Steelers.
Quarterback: Allen will be catching passes from Justin Herbert, while Johnson will be catching passes from Mitchell Trubisky.
ADP: Allen is currently being drafted as the WR10 in fantasy football, while Johnson is being drafted as the WR15.

1. Age

Age is an important factor to consider when evaluating Keenan Allen and Diontae Johnson for fantasy football. Allen is 30 years old, while Johnson is 26. This means that Johnson is entering his prime, while Allen is starting to decline. This is reflected in their respective ADP's, as Johnson is being drafted as the WR15, while Allen is being drafted as the WR10.

Of course, age is not the only factor to consider when evaluating these two players. Allen has more experience and has been more productive in his career than Johnson. However, Johnson is a rising star and has the potential to be a top-10 wide receiver in the NFL. If you are looking for a safe, reliable option, then Allen is your guy. But if you are looking for a player with a higher upside, then Johnson is the better choice.

2. Experience

Keenan Allen has been in the NFL for seven seasons, while Diontae Johnson has been in the NFL for three seasons. This difference in experience is significant, as Allen has had more time to develop his skills and learn the NFL game. He has also had more time to build rapport with his quarterbacks and teammates. As a result, Allen is a more polished and complete wide receiver than Johnson.

Experience is important in all aspects of life, but it is especially important in sports. In the NFL, players need to be able to adjust to the speed and physicality of the game. They also need to be able to learn and execute complex playbooks. Allen has had more time to do all of these things than Johnson, and it shows in his play.

Of course, experience is not the only factor that determines a player's success. Johnson is a talented player with a lot of potential. However, Allen's experience gives him an edge over Johnson, especially in close games or high-pressure situations.

When evaluating Keenan Allen and Diontae Johnson for fantasy football, it is important to consider their experience. Allen's experience gives him an edge over Johnson, and he is the safer choice for fantasy owners.

3. Stats

When evaluating Keenan Allen and Diontae Johnson for fantasy football, it is important to consider their stats. Allen has more career receptions and receiving yards than Johnson, but Johnson has a higher career yards per reception average. This means that Johnson is more efficient with his touches than Allen. He is able to gain more yards per reception, which is a valuable trait for a wide receiver.

There are a few reasons why Johnson has a higher yards per reception average than Allen. First, Johnson is a more explosive player. He has good speed and acceleration, which allows him to create separation from defenders and gain yards after the catch. Second, Johnson is a very good route runner. He is able to find soft spots in the defense and get open for big plays. Third, Johnson has a good quarterback in Ben Roethlisberger. Roethlisberger is able to put the ball in Johnson's hands in a variety of ways, which helps Johnson to produce big plays.

Of course, Allen is still a very good wide receiver. He is a reliable target who can make big plays. However, Johnson's efficiency and explosiveness give him a slight edge over Allen in fantasy football.

4. Team

The team that a player plays for can have a significant impact on their fantasy value. This is because the team's offensive scheme, quarterback play, and overall talent level can all affect a player's production.

In the case of Keenan Allen and Diontae Johnson, both players play for teams with high-powered offenses. The Chargers have one of the most talented offenses in the NFL, led by quarterback Justin Herbert. The Steelers also have a talented offense, led by quarterback Ben Roethlisberger. Both quarterbacks are known for their ability to spread the ball around to their receivers, which benefits both Allen and Johnson.

However, there are some key differences between the two teams. The Chargers have a more pass-happy offense than the Steelers. This means that Allen is likely to see more targets and have more opportunities to produce big plays. The Steelers, on the other hand, have a more balanced offense. This means that Johnson may not see as many targets as Allen, but he could still be a valuable fantasy asset if he can produce efficiently.

Ultimately, the team that a player plays for is just one factor to consider when evaluating them for fantasy football. However, it is an important factor to consider, as it can give you a good idea of how many opportunities a player is likely to have to produce.

5. Quarterback

When evaluating Keenan Allen and Diontae Johnson for fantasy football, it is important to consider the quarterbacks they will be catching passes from. Allen will be catching passes from Justin Herbert, while Johnson will be catching passes from Mitchell Trubisky.

Justin Herbert
Justin Herbert is one of the most promising young quarterbacks in the NFL. He has a strong arm and is very accurate. He is also very mobile, which allows him to extend plays and make big plays. Herbert is a rising star, and he is expected to be one of the best quarterbacks in the NFL for many years to come.
Mitchell Trubisky
Mitchell Trubisky is a solid quarterback, but he is not in the same class as Herbert. He has a good arm, but he is not as accurate as Herbert. He is also not as mobile as Herbert. Trubisky is a good quarterback, but he is not a great quarterback. He is capable of having a good season, but he is also capable of having a bad season.

In summary, Justin Herbert is a better quarterback than Mitchell Trubisky. This gives Keenan Allen a slight edge over Diontae Johnson in fantasy football.

6. ADP

When evaluating Keenan Allen and Diontae Johnson for fantasy football, it is important to consider their ADP. ADP stands for Average Draft Position, and it is a measure of how early a player is being drafted in fantasy football drafts. Players with a lower ADP are typically considered to be more valuable than players with a higher ADP.

ADP and Value
ADP can be a good indicator of a player's value. Players with a lower ADP are typically considered to be more valuable than players with a higher ADP.
ADP and Team Strategy
ADP can also be a factor in team strategy. If you are drafting a team with a lot of high-ADP players, you may not be able to afford to draft a player like Keenan Allen. However, if you are drafting a team with a lot of value players, you may be able to get Allen at a discount.
ADP and Risk
ADP can also be a factor in risk assessment. Players with a lower ADP are typically considered to be less risky than players with a higher ADP. This is because players with a lower ADP have already been vetted by other fantasy owners, and they are less likely to bust.
ADP and Upside
ADP can also be a factor in upside. Players with a lower ADP typically have less upside than players with a higher ADP. This is because players with a lower ADP have already been priced into their value, and there is less room for them to exceed expectations.

In the case of Keenan Allen and Diontae Johnson, Allen has a lower ADP than Johnson. This means that Allen is considered to be a more valuable player than Johnson. However, it is important to note that ADP is just one factor to consider when evaluating players for fantasy football. Other factors, such as team, quarterback, and schedule, should also be considered.

FAQs about Keenan Allen and Diontae Johnson

Keenan Allen and Diontae Johnson are two of the most talented wide receivers in the NFL. Both players have had success at the highest level, but who is the better choice for your fantasy team?

Here are five frequently asked questions about Keenan Allen and Diontae Johnson:

7. Question 1: Which player is older?

Keenan Allen is 30 years old, while Diontae Johnson is 26 years old.

8. Question 2: Which player has more experience?

Keenan Allen has been in the NFL since 2013, while Diontae Johnson has been in the NFL since 2019.

9. Question 3: Which player has better stats?

Keenan Allen has more career receptions and receiving yards than Diontae Johnson, but Johnson has a higher career yards per reception average.

10. Question 4: Which player plays for a better team?

Keenan Allen plays for the Los Angeles Chargers, while Diontae Johnson plays for the Pittsburgh Steelers. The Chargers have a more pass-happy offense than the Steelers, which means that Allen is likely to see more targets and have more opportunities to produce big plays.

11. Question 5: Which player has a better quarterback?

Keenan Allen will be catching passes from Justin Herbert, while Diontae Johnson will be catching passes from Mitchell Trubisky. Justin Herbert is one of the most promising young quarterbacks in the NFL, while Mitchell Trubisky is a solid quarterback but not in the same class as Herbert.

Transition to the next article section...

Conclusion

Keenan Allen and Diontae Johnson are two of the most talented wide receivers in the NFL. Both players have had success at the highest level, but they have different skill sets and play for different teams. When evaluating Allen and Johnson for fantasy football, it is important to consider their age, experience, stats, team, quarterback, and ADP.