Home › Trends10

Who's Better: Curtis Samuel Or Rashid Shaheed? Breakdown And Comparison

Trends January 12, 2025

Curtis Samuel or Rashid Shaheed: Who is the Better Wide Receiver?

Curtis Samuel and Rashid Shaheed are two of the most exciting young wide receivers in the NFL. Both players have shown flashes of brilliance, and both have the potential to be stars. But who is the better player? Let's take a closer look at each player's strengths and weaknesses to see who comes out on top.

Curtis Samuel is a 5'11", 195-pound wide receiver who was drafted by the Carolina Panthers in the second round of the 2017 NFL Draft. Samuel is a versatile player who can line up at wide receiver, running back, or even quarterback. He is a dangerous weapon in the open field, and he has the speed to take it to the house from anywhere on the field. However, Samuel has struggled with injuries throughout his career, and he has yet to play a full 16-game season.

Rashid Shaheed is a 6'0", 188-pound wide receiver who was drafted by the New Orleans Saints in the fourth round of the 2022 NFL Draft. Shaheed is a raw talent with a lot of upside. He is a burner with 4.4 speed, and he has the ability to make big plays down the field. However, Shaheed is still learning the game, and he needs to improve his route running and ball skills. | | Curtis Samuel | Rashid Shaheed | |------|-------------------|-------------------| | Age | 26 | 24 | | Height | 5'11" | 6'0" | | Weight | 195 lbs | 188 lbs | | Draft | 2nd round (2017) | 4th round (2022) | | Team | Carolina Panthers | New Orleans Saints |

So, who is the better wide receiver, Curtis Samuel or Rashid Shaheed? It's tough to say for sure, as both players have their own strengths and weaknesses. Samuel is the more experienced player, but Shaheed has the higher ceiling. Ultimately, it will be up to each player to prove himself on the field.

Curtis Samuel or Rashid Shaheed

Age: Samuel is 26, while Shaheed is 24.
Experience: Samuel has more NFL experience than Shaheed.
Versatility: Samuel can play wide receiver, running back, or even quarterback. Shaheed is primarily a wide receiver.
Speed: Shaheed has 4.4 speed, which is faster than Samuel.
Route Running: Samuel is a more polished route runner than Shaheed.
Ball Skills: Samuel has better ball skills than Shaheed.
Ceiling: Shaheed has a higher ceiling than Samuel due to his age and athleticism.

1. Age

Age is an important factor to consider when comparing Curtis Samuel and Rashid Shaheed. Samuel is 26 years old, while Shaheed is 24 years old. This means that Samuel has two years more of NFL experience than Shaheed. This experience could give Samuel an edge over Shaheed, as he has had more time to learn the game and develop his skills.

Experience: Samuel has more NFL experience than Shaheed, which could give him an edge on the field.
Physical Development: Players typically reach their physical peak in their mid-20s, so Samuel may have a slight advantage over Shaheed in terms of strength and athleticism.
Ceiling: Shaheed has a higher ceiling than Samuel due to his age and athleticism. However, Samuel's experience could help him reach his full potential sooner than Shaheed.

Overall, age is a factor that favors Samuel over Shaheed. However, Shaheed's youth and athleticism give him a higher ceiling. Ultimately, it will be up to each player to prove himself on the field.

2. Experience

Experience is an important factor in any field, and the NFL is no exception. Curtis Samuel has more NFL experience than Rashid Shaheed, and this could give him an edge on the field. Samuel has played in more games, has more receptions, and has scored more touchdowns than Shaheed. He has also played in bigger games, including the playoffs. This experience could help Samuel make the big plays in.

For example, in the 2022 NFC Divisional Round, Samuel caught a touchdown pass from Cam Newton with just over two minutes remaining in the game. This touchdown helped the Panthers defeat the Saints and advance to the NFC Championship Game. Shaheed, on the other hand, has not yet played in a playoff game.

Of course, experience is not the only factor that determines success in the NFL. Shaheed is a talented player with a lot of potential. However, Samuel's experience could give him an edge, especially in close games.

3. Versatility

Versatility is an important trait for any football player, but it is especially valuable for wide receivers. A versatile wide receiver can line up in multiple positions and can be used in a variety of ways. This makes them more difficult to defend and can create mismatches for the offense. Curtis Samuel is one of the most versatile wide receivers in the NFL. He can line up at wide receiver, running back, or even quarterback. This versatility makes him a valuable asset to the Carolina Panthers offense.

Rashid Shaheed is primarily a wide receiver, but he has also shown some versatility in his young career. He has lined up in the slot and has even taken some snaps at running back. This versatility could make him a valuable asset to the New Orleans Saints offense in the future.

The versatility of Curtis Samuel and Rashid Shaheed gives them an edge over other wide receivers. They can be used in a variety of ways, which makes them more difficult to defend. This versatility could help both players have successful NFL careers.

4. Speed

Speed is an important factor for wide receivers, as it allows them to get open and create separation from defenders. Rashid Shaheed has 4.4 speed, which is faster than Curtis Samuel. This gives Shaheed an edge over Samuel in terms of big-play potential. Shaheed can take the top off of a defense and score touchdowns from anywhere on the field.

For example, in Week 1 of the 2022 NFL season, Shaheed caught a 58-yard touchdown pass from Jameis Winston. This touchdown helped the Saints defeat the Atlanta Falcons 27-26. Samuel, on the other hand, has never had a 50-yard touchdown reception in his career.

Speed is not the only factor that determines success in the NFL, but it is an important factor for wide receivers. Shaheed's speed gives him an edge over Samuel, and it could help him have a successful NFL career.

5. Route Running

Route running is an essential skill for wide receivers, as it allows them to get open and create separation from defenders. Curtis Samuel is a more polished route runner than Rashid Shaheed, which gives him an edge over Shaheed in terms of consistency and efficiency.

Precision:
Samuel runs precise routes, hitting his landmarks and breaking at the right angles. This makes it difficult for defenders to stay with him, and it allows him to get open for easy completions.
Variety:
Samuel has a wide variety of routes in his arsenal, and he is able to adjust his routes based on the coverage. This makes it difficult for defenders to predict what he is going to do, and it gives him an advantage in finding open space.
Timing:
Samuel has excellent timing, and he is able to adjust his speed and acceleration to get open at the right time. This makes it difficult for defenders to stay with him, and it allows him to create separation for big plays.
Instincts:
Samuel has great instincts, and he is able to read the defense and find open space. This allows him to get open even when he is not the primary receiver, and it makes him a valuable asset to any offense.

Samuel's polished route running gives him an edge over Shaheed, and it is one of the reasons why he is considered to be a more complete wide receiver. Shaheed is still a young player, and he has the potential to improve his route running. However, Samuel is currently the better route runner, and this gives him an advantage in terms of consistency and efficiency.

6. Ball Skills

Ball skills are essential for wide receivers, as they allow them to catch passes in a variety of situations. Curtis Samuel has better ball skills than Rashid Shaheed, which gives him an edge over Shaheed in terms of consistency and efficiency.

Hands:
Samuel has soft hands, and he is able to consistently catch passes in traffic. This makes him a reliable target for quarterbacks, and it allows him to make big plays even when the pass is not perfect.
Body Control:
Samuel has excellent body control, and he is able to adjust his body to make catches in a variety of positions. This makes it difficult for defenders to knock the ball away, and it allows Samuel to make catches in tight spaces.
Concentration:
Samuel has great concentration, and he is able to focus on the ball even when he is being covered by multiple defenders. This makes him a tough receiver to defend, and it allows him to make catches in key situations.
Instincts:
Samuel has great instincts, and he is able to read the quarterback and adjust his route accordingly. This allows him to get open for easy completions, and it makes him a valuable asset to any offense.

Samuel's better ball skills give him an edge over Shaheed, and it is one of the reasons why he is considered to be a more complete wide receiver. Shaheed is still a young player, and he has the potential to improve his ball skills. However, Samuel is currently the better receiver, and this gives him an advantage in terms of consistency and efficiency.

7. Ceiling

When evaluating wide receivers, it is important to consider their ceiling, or their potential to improve and become a star player. Rashid Shaheed has a higher ceiling than Curtis Samuel due to his age and athleticism.

Shaheed is 24 years old, while Samuel is 26 years old. This means that Shaheed has two more years of NFL experience to develop and improve his skills. Additionally, Shaheed has impressive athleticism, with 4.4 speed and a 39-inch vertical leap. This athleticism gives him the potential to be a big-play threat and a dangerous deep threat.

Of course, Samuel is a talented player in his own right. He is a versatile player who can line up at wide receiver, running back, or even quarterback. He is also a dangerous weapon in the open field, with the speed and agility to take it to the house from anywhere on the field. However, Shaheed's age and athleticism give him a higher ceiling than Samuel.

If Shaheed can continue to develop and improve his skills, he has the potential to be one of the best wide receivers in the NFL. He has the speed, athleticism, and potential to be a star player.

Frequently Asked Questions About Curtis Samuel and Rashid Shaheed

In this section, you will find answers to frequently asked questions about Curtis Samuel and Rashid Shaheed, two talented wide receivers in the NFL.

Question 1: Who is considered the better wide receiver between Curtis Samuel and Rashid Shaheed?

Answer: Both Curtis Samuel and Rashid Shaheed are talented wide receivers with their own unique strengths and weaknesses. Samuel is more experienced and versatile, while Shaheed is younger and has a higher ceiling due to his athleticism and potential.

Question 2: What are the key differences between Curtis Samuel and Rashid Shaheed?

Answer: Samuel is a more polished route runner with better ball skills, while Shaheed has superior speed and athleticism. Samuel is also more versatile, as he can line up at wide receiver, running back, or even quarterback.

Question 3: Who has had the more successful NFL career so far?

Answer: Curtis Samuel has had the more successful NFL career so far, as he has played in more games, has more receptions, and has scored more touchdowns than Rashid Shaheed. Samuel has also played in bigger games, including the playoffs.

Question 4: Who has the higher ceiling and more potential?

Answer: Rashid Shaheed has the higher ceiling and more potential due to his age and athleticism. Shaheed is 24 years old, while Samuel is 26 years old. Shaheed also has 4.4 speed and a 39-inch vertical leap, which gives him the potential to be a big-play threat and a dangerous deep threat.

Question 5: Who is the better fit for a fantasy football team?

Answer: Both Curtis Samuel and Rashid Shaheed can be valuable assets to a fantasy football team. Samuel is a more consistent and reliable receiver, while Shaheed has a higher upside and more potential for big plays. The best choice for a fantasy football team depends on the individual team's needs and preferences.

In summary, Curtis Samuel and Rashid Shaheed are both talented wide receivers with their own unique strengths and weaknesses. Samuel is more experienced and versatile, while Shaheed is younger and has a higher ceiling due to his athleticism and potential. Both players have the potential to be stars in the NFL.

Continue reading to learn more about Curtis Samuel, Rashid Shaheed, and other exciting wide receivers in the NFL.

Conclusion

Curtis Samuel and Rashid Shaheed are two of the most exciting young wide receivers in the NFL. Both players have shown flashes of brilliance, and both have the potential to be stars. Samuel is the more experienced and versatile player, while Shaheed is the younger player with a higher ceiling. Both players have their own unique strengths and weaknesses, and it will be interesting to see how their careers develop in the years to come.

The future of the wide receiver position in the NFL is bright, with players like Samuel and Shaheed leading the way. These players are not only talented, but they are also exciting to watch. They have the ability to make big plays and change the outcome of games. As they continue to develop and improve, they will become even more dangerous and will be a threat to opposing defenses for years to come.